Gershom Gorenberg

Gershom Gorenberg is a senior correspondent for The Prospect. He is the author of The Unmaking of Israel, of The Accidental Empire: Israel and the Birth of the Settlements, 1967-1977 and of The End of Days: Fundamentalism and the Struggle for the Temple Mount. He blogs at South Jerusalem. Follow @GershomG.

Recent Articles

Why Bernie's Socialism Doesn't Make Him Anti-Zionist

It makes no sense to portray Sanders as leading a charge against Israel. 

AP Photo/Steve Helber, File
AP Photo/Steve Helber, File In this September 14, 2015, file photo, Liberty University students listen as Democratic presidential candidate, Senator Bernie Sanders, gestures during a speech at Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia. H ere's a certain version of history: Once, in a different era, the era into which Bernie Sanders was born, “New York was full of Yiddish socialists.” Jews, or very large numbers of them, continued leaning left until the late 1960s, when right-wing Zionism took over as the moving spirit of American Jewish life. Universalism, sadly, gave way to exceptionalism. Sanders, though, is an “evangelist” of the old socialist tradition, “the kind of Jew that Zionists would very much like us to forget.” In very brief form, that's the account in Jesse Myerson's cover story in the Village Voice a few days ago. A colleague sent me a link, which reached me on a stopover between North America and my small Hebrew-speaking country in the Middle East. It's a strange read...

It Doesn't Matter What Trump Said about Israel. It Matters That He Got to Say It.

First Adelson tilted toward Trump, then AIPAC gave him a counterfeit stamp of legitimacy.

AP Photo/Evan Vucci
AP Photo/Evan Vucci Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks at the 2016 American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) Policy Conference at the Verizon Center, on Monday, March 21, 2016, in Washington. T he day before Donald Trump spoke at the AIPAC conference in Washington, the top morning talk show on Israel Radio began with commentary on a proposal to lower the voting age in Israel to 17. “Getting young people into the voting booth sounds wonderful,” said co-anchor Beni Teitelbaum. “The question is whether this will accelerate a trend of putting reality TV stars in parliament, because young people will en masse vote for the star ... of some passing televised nonsense.” Teitelbaum is on the political right and has a left-wing partner on the show, which usually begins with one making a pointed remark about a news item and the other rebutting it. This time the left-wing host said nothing, signaling agreement. There are several ex-journalists in Israel's parliament, but...

When Your Enemy's Enemy is Your Enemy

A defense of Hezbollah by two Israeli Arab parties is a lesson for progressives on the pitfalls of obsolete rhetoric.

AP Photo/Mohammed Zaatari
AP Photo/Mohammed Zaatari Hezbollah fighters march in a parade during the memorial of their slain leader Sheik Abbas al-Mousawi, who was killed by an Israeli airstrike in 1992, in Tefahta village, south Lebanon, Saturday, February 13, 2016. T hree news items from the strange political morass known as the Middle East: ◦ Last week, the Gulf Cooperation Council—a six-country Arab alliance dominated by Saudi Arabia—officially designated Hezbollah as a terror organization, laying the ground for harsh legal steps against anyone connected with the Lebanese Shi'ite group. ◦ This week two political parties representing Palestinian citizens of Israel condemned the GCC decision. Hezbollah had come to the aid of Lebanon against Israel aggression and “stands in the breach against American-Israeli efforts to impose hegemony,” said a resolution of the National Democratic Assembly. A similar statement was published in the name of the Democratic Front for Peace and Equality. (The former party is often...

Isaac Herzog: The Man With Small Answers

The leader of Israel's Labor Party says he has the solution for the diplomatic deadlock. But he's really part of the problem.

AP Photo/Ariel Schalit
AP Photo/Ariel Schalit Israeli leader of the center-left Zionist Union Isaac Herzog speaks with Israeli voters persuading them to vote for him in the upcoming Israeli elections in his party headquarters in Tel Aviv, Israel, Monday, March 16, 2015 a day ahead of legislative elections. I saac Herzog, the nominal and ineffectual leader of the Israeli opposition, has found what he believes to be a platform for challenging Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu: despair of reaching a two-state agreement in the foreseeable future. The main lesson of this exercise is that despair is not an inspiring political message. But then, Herzog has never been accused of being an inspiring politician. Despair does not provide a reason to act; it is an excuse for failing to do so. The danger of Herzog's despair isn't just that it will provide the current Israeli government with one more PR argument for inaction, but that it will also fuel the sense in other capitals that there's nothing to be done about the...

They Don't Mind Being Called McCarthyites

A process of political selection in the Israeli right favors paranoia and disregard for democracy.

Abir Sultan, Pool Photo via AP, File
Abir Sultan, Pool Photo via AP, File In this January 18, 2015, file photo, Israeli Education Minister Naftali Bennett speaks with the media ahead of a weekly cabinet meeting in Jerusalem. “ In most cases, it turned out he was right,” Ronen Shoval tweeted in Hebrew a few days ago. The “he” in that sentence refers to Joseph McCarthy. Shoval, founder of the attack-dog organization Im Tirtzu, was responding to critics who charge his organization and its allies in government with McCarthyism, as described here in Peter Dreier's article this week. Shoval's answer was to happily accept the label. He's not alone. Knesset Member Ofir Akunis of Prime Minister's Benjamin Netanyahu's Likud party once responded to the same charge on a TV talk show with, “Every word [McCarthy] said was correct.” Shoval sometimes plays the part of McCarthy so well that one wonders if he knows that the Cold War is over. In an interview with me five years ago, he not only accused the New Israel Fund (NIF) of “aiding...

Pages