Worst-Case Scenarios

In David Frum’s most recent op-ed, he describes the “menu of possibilities” for non-Tea Party Republicans in 2012. His second possibility –- in which Mitt Romney wins the nomination but loses the general election -– is one I’ve been thinking about for some time. Here is Frum’s assessment of what might happen as a result of that outcome:

If candidate Romney loses, tea party Republicans will claim that the GOP lost because it failed to nominate a “true conservative.” That claim may fly in the face of political math (how would a more extreme candidate win more votes?), but it will pack a lot of emotional punch…Back-to-back losses under John McCain in 2008 and Mitt Romney in 2012 will open the way to an ultra-conservative nominee in 2016 – and a true party debacle.

If you take the view that today’s Republican Party is dangerously extreme in its rejection of institutional norms and raw pursuit of power –- and that this stands to do huge damage to America in the long-term –- then the best outcome for 2012 is one in which a representative of this militant conservatism, like Rick Perry, is decisively beaten at the polls. In this world, electoral defeat will lead Republicans to re-evaluate their vision of conservative utopia, reject the extremists, and rejoin the Democratic Party as a responsible governing partner.

The issue with Mitt Romney, as Frum points out, is that if he loses, the odds are slim that right-wing Republicans will walk away chastened. Tea Party Republicans can easily tar Romney as just another liberal and double-down on the right-wing extremism in hopes of nominating a “real conservative” to the top of the GOP presidential ticket. For the rest of us, this means another four years of instransigence, brinksmanship, and a casual disregard for the norms of governance.

On the other hand, if Romney wins the election, there’s a chance that Republicans will feel vindicated in their strategy of the last three years, in which case, we can expect government to grind to a complete halt, as Democrats seek to replicate the tactics of congressional Republicans and their allies.

You need to be logged in to comment.
(If there's one thing we know about comment trolls, it's that they're lazy)

Connect
, after login or registration your account will be connected.
Advertisement