George W. Bush

Rove's Pride.

So Karl Rove is "proud" of waterboarding, which means he's proud of the fact that his administration disgraced the United States with torture. I'm not sure what else he was supposed to say -- the only possible justification he has is that some good might have come out of his administration breaking the law. Matthew Yglesias has noted this inconsistency with torture defenders -- what does it matter if waterboarding was torture if it was indeed so effective and saved so many lives?

Ted Olson's Two-fer.

Ted Olson, a former solicitor general under George W. Bush who lost his wife in the September 11 attacks, has become the latest conservative luminary to come out against Liz Cheney's McCarthyite ad, which accuses Justice Department lawyers who did work on behalf of suspected terror detainees of disloyalty.

Olson, though, seems to think that there's an equivalence between say, criticizing John Yoo and Jay Bybee's rubber-stamping of torture and ensuring detainees have due process (via Ben Smith):

Another Bush Official Defends Smeared DoJ Lawyers.

John Bellinger III, a former legal adviser to Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice and currently a partner at the law firm of Arnold and Porter, defended the nine Department of Justice lawyers who have been accused of being terrorist sympathizers by Liz Cheney's group, Keep America Safe.

“I think it’s unfortunate that these individuals are being criticized for their past representation. It reflects the politicization and the polarization of terrorism issues," Bellinger said. "Neither Republicans nor Democrats should be attacking officials in each other’s administrations based solely on the clients they have represented in the past.”

Keep America Safe Already Wavering On McCarthyist Ad.

Liz Cheney and her organization, Keep America Safe, seem to be playing defense because of the backlash from their latest ad, which accuses Justice Department lawyers who represented accused terror detainees terrorist sympathizers.

Yesterday, Keep America Safe Spokesman Aaron Harison, in an interview with Main Justice, struggled to argue that, in fact, they weren't suggesting that at all:

Going On Offense.

The torture wing of the GOP is a lot of things, but I don't think they're too dumb to understand how the American legal system works. Attorneys who defend rapists do not approve of rape, attorneys who defend murderers do not approve of murder. There's nothing sinister about believing the government should prove its case against those it accuses of crimes -- that kind of basic accountability is essential to a functioning democracy. As Thomas Paine said, "He that would make his own liberty secure, must guard even his enemy from oppression."

Republican "Mirandization" Ploy Fails.

House Republicans failed in an attempt to insert into the Intelligence Authorization Act an amendment that would have seriously micromanaged the executive branch, requiring the director of National Intelligence's "personal and prior approval before mirandizing a terrorist suspect." The motion to recommit failed by a vote of 186-217.

Alan Simpson Is Pretty Reasonable, Actually.

boxing_alan_simpson.jpgDean Baker, our favorite pugnacious progressive economist, calls out Alan Simpson, the Republican former senator that Obama tapped to lead his new deficit reduction panel.

Labor's Loss.

The same day that congressional leaders met in an effort to find bipartisan accord and Obama urged Congress to get beyond "petty politics," petty politics reigned. Republicans, and a few Democrats, successfully blocked the appointment of Craig Becker, a union lawyer, to the National Labor Relations Board.

Bush Touted Civilian Terror Convictions in 2009 Budget.

Conservatives like Andy McCarthy have been challenging Justice Department numbers indicating that more than 300 convicted terrorists reside in American prisons, convicted by the criminal justice system. The numbers undermine the conservative case against using courts instead of military commissions to handle terrorism cases: 

Clarke: GOP Exploiting Terrorism For Political Gain.

Via David Schorr, former Bill Clinton- and George W. Bush-era counterterrorism adviser Richard Clarke accuses the GOP of positioning themselves in order to take advantage of a terrorist attack. Noting that the Obama administration's approach to handling the failed underwear bomber was consistent with that of prior administrations, Clarke writes:

All Disasters Involving Black People Are The Same!

Howard Fineman is out the gate with your liberal racial paternalism of the day, connecting Haiti to Hurricane Katrina because, well, they both involve black people and natural disasters. Get it?

And, adding irony upon irony, the racial context of New Orleans is writ large in Port-au-Prince. Katrina cost George W. Bush what little standing he had among moderates in his own party in part because the shocking images of suffering in New Orleans were so racially imbalanced.

Hating Us For Our Freedoms.

At this point, Charles Krauthammer is like Andy McCarthy, if McCarthy could turn a phrase. Here Krauthammer argues the "system worked" -- for Umar Abdulmutallab:

What he lost in flying privileges he gained in Miranda rights. He was singing quite freely when seized after trying to bring down Northwest Flight 253 over Detroit. But the Obama administration decided to give him a lawyer and the right to remain silent. We are now forced to purchase information from this attempted terrorist in the coin of leniency. Absurdly, Abdulmutallab is now in control.

[...]

Baker: On Terrorism, Obama Isn't All That Different From Bush.

Look, I've been yelling my head off about this for a while, but hopefully it'll sink in now that Peter Baker has said it in his monster Times Magazine piece on the Obama administration's national security policy:

The Cards You're Dealt.

A number of Republicans have pointed to this Rasmussen poll showing a majority of Americans would want the alleged underwear bomber Umar Abdulmutallab waterboarded as proof that the GOP is "winning" the national security debate. Certainly American acceptance of torture has increased over time, but I suspect that has more to do with, now that Bush is out of office, being able to embrace torture openly -- rather than having to sound ambivalent or dissemble about whether waterboarding is torture.

Perez Blasts The Bush-Era Civil Rights Division.

The new Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights, Thomas Perez, blasted the Bush administration's stewardship of the Civil Rights Division of the Justice Department today at an American Constitution Society event, reprising the "buffet line" quip he used yesterday but far more directly.

Pages