Just when Microsoft was fixing an Outlook glitch that caused hundreds of millions of people to lose network connections, a grounding of all U.S. flights Friday afternoon knocked that mess off the front pages and threw the travel plans of millions of passengers into chaos.

As far as we know, neither was the result of malicious hacks. But how would we know?

The lack of transparency and oversight that is the signature of Big Tech leaves regulators in the dark about what really caused the Outlook outage. The air traffic shutdown was the result of antiquated systems that the Trump administration, obsessed with trashing government, has done little to overhaul. A hack would have been gratuitous.

Today on TAP

This story first appeared in our free Today on TAP newsletter, a weekday email featuring commentary on the daily news from Prospect reporters.

No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for Today on TAP, our weekday afternoon newsletter.

President Trump’s idea of modernizing infrastructure is the East Wing ballroom, the personal seizure of D.C.’s public golf course, and his triumphal arch, not the mundane details of public systems that serve regular people. At a combative press conference on the need for FAA upgrades, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy could not explain why he was suddenly demanding $50 billion from Congress to modernize air traffic control, while the administration’s big beautiful budget had requested only $12.5 billion, much of which has not yet even been obligated, much less spent.

The long-standing FAA problems were hardly a secret. One report after another has warned that system collapses like the one over the weekend were inevitable. A recent report by the Government Accountability Office warned, “FAA has not developed an integrated master schedule for phase 1 [of its system overhaul]. Instead, FAA has 11,389 individual project schedules that are not integrated.”

This particular shutdown was the result of the bungled upgrade of a router at a single FAA facility in El Dorado, Arkansas. On Friday, after the FAA contractor, L3Harris, installed a new router made by manufacturer HPE’s Juniper Networks, the machine at the Arkansas location began mistakenly sending out a massive volume of data, which overwhelmed the entire national air traffic control system. Usually, these kinds of upgrades happen in the middle of the night, not at the start of a busy travel weekend.

Was this the fault of the contractor? The manufacturer? A recent merger by the manufacturer with its only competitor? Inadequate FAA supervision? Congress will have to sort that out. But this level of detail is not the sort of thing that gets Sean Duffy up in the morning.

Hackers did not need to disable America’s air traffic control system because it was disabling itself.

Rather than accelerating and monitoring the process of upgrading the basic air traffic control system, Duffy has been preoccupied with launching a parallel system called START that is a sweetheart favor to a startup created by several alumni of Palantir. In June, the new company, called Air Space Intelligence (ASI), was given a 12-year, $875.95 million contract without any competitive bidding process. The START system supposedly will use AI to improve air traffic control. Duffy, following Trump’s example, is pursuing the idea of the government taking an equity position in the company.

Duffy and executives of ASI were quick to insist that START did not contribute to the system failure; and indeed, it is not yet integrated into the basic air traffic control system. But of course, neither does it contribute to the long-overdue basic upgrade. It’s one more source of complexity atop an overwhelmed and antiquated system. Democrats in Congress have called for a 90-day pause until START can be better evaluated.

So there you have it. The mass grounding reflects the Trump administration’s signature blend of corruption and incompetence. And more such groundings are baked in.

Hackers did not need to disable America’s air traffic control system because it was disabling itself. But if you want to get absolutely ill, have a look at this roster of several dozen major hacking successes by nations such as Russia, China, and Iran, compiled by the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

One of the most recent is the puzzling hack of France’s commercial refrigeration systems. During the night of October 11-12, hackers took over the computer systems that control refrigeration at some 700 locations in France. The operation gained access to refrigeration controllers, changed the settings to raise temperatures, and disabled alerts. This caused the loss of millions of dollars’ worth of frozen meat and other foods at major supermarket chains.

According to the official French government report of November 9, the source of the hack was a cyber warfare unit of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) called Shahid Kaveh, which reports to the Iranian supreme commander. This was a disturbing demonstration of Iran’s capacity to conduct sophisticated cyber warfare.

Today on TAP

This story first appeared in our free Today on TAP newsletter, a weekday email featuring commentary on the daily news from Prospect reporters.

No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for Today on TAP, our weekday afternoon newsletter.

But why France, which is a secondary player in the Gulf war? And why the industrial freezers of French supermarket chains?

The speculation is that it was intended as a demonstration and a warning. If remote Iranian hackers can disable French refrigeration systems, they can also disable U.S. electric power systems, water supply systems, the internet, and if we ever fix it, air traffic control.

When news bulletins reported that all planes were grounded, many Americans thought of the attacks of September 11, 2001. What if Trump’s incompetence really did lead to a catastrophic foreign cyber attack? Just like George W. Bush in the months after 9/11, Trump would try to be rescued from his own disastrous reign by panicking the public and demanding new emergency powers.

In the bad old days of government regulation, the mass-communication predecessor of the internet—the telephone system—was closely regulated in the public interest. Likewise the airlines. And the intelligence community was actually serious about monitoring and disabling foreign threats.

Today, government has been turned over to corrupt private purposes. Tech is the Wild West. AI is seen as an opportunity for personal gain rather than a policy challenge. Pete Hegseth has fired senior people at the Cyber Command who actually took cyber threats seriously. The FCC has been turned into an agency of censorship and propaganda.

We will be sitting ducks for cyber catastrophes, whether self-inflicted or imposed by enemies, until we elect a government that is both public-minded and competent.

Robert Kuttner is co-founder and co-editor of The American Prospect, and professor at Brandeis University’s Heller School. His latest book is Notes for Next Time: Surviving Tyranny, Redeeming America.