Read the top story of the day in your inbox. Sign up for the Daily Prospect newsletter here.
Republicans are rushing to install a Trump loyalist as head of the Government Accountability Office (GAO), the only federal agency with statutory authority to sue the executive branch for illegally withholding or impounding funds appropriated by Congress.
Their intended comptroller general, the GAO’s leader, is Eric Ueland, deputy director of the Office of Management and Budget (OMB). He’s the right-hand man of Christian nationalist OMB director Russell Vought, an architect of Project 2025. Together, they have led the Trump administration’s efforts to withhold funds for public services, gut the federal workforce, and redistribute taxpayer money to Trump allies and favored projects.
The Prospect in your inbox
Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.
No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.
Members of the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee (HSGAC) will hear from Ueland at a hearing this Thursday. The hearing has been scheduled for a week, but Ueland’s name was not officially published online until yesterday afternoon. The Washington Sun reported earlier this month that Trump was considering Ueland for the job; sources confirmed the information to the Federal News Network and the Prospect before the government made it public.
The appointment is part of Republicans’ continuing effort to halt Democrats’ executive branch oversight before it can even start next year when they take over Congress. “My suspicion is that Republicans, or the White House specifically, didn’t realize that there was a real chance that they could lose the Senate,” American Governance Institute Executive Director Daniel Schuman said of the nomination. “Once they did, they decided to … destroy the agency that is investigating them.”
Ueland’s appointment would prevent staff from doing their jobs and drive a mass exodus, Schuman said. In short: “It would be a nightmare.”
The GAO is an independent, nonpartisan watchdog that investigates and audits how the government spends taxpayers’ money. It provides oversight information to lawmakers and federal agencies to make programs and operations more efficient; during the last fiscal year, it identified $62.5 billion in savings, according to its annual performance and accountability assessment.
Among its most recent reports, the GAO advised how to improve immigrant detention camps, federal prisons, Health and Human Services spending, military personnel humanitarian reassignments, and young children’s preparedness for kindergarten.
The president appoints the agency’s leader, who until last December was Gene L. Dodaro, who stepped down after he reached the statutory term limit of 15 years. Since then, acting Comptroller General Orice W. Brown has led the agency.
But Congress has more advise-and-consent responsibilities over the GAO leadership than other presidential appointments. Federal law requires Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Chair Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) to convene a ten-person bipartisan commission of Senate and House members, who then recommend three candidates for the president to consider.
Paul hasn’t done that. He never convened the panel, initiated an application process, or interviewed potential candidates, as required. Instead, Paul’s staff asked Senate Democratic offices for their recommendations for comptroller general last Wednesday afternoon, during the Veterans Day holiday, with a deadline of 8 a.m. the next morning.
His process “appears to be a partisan, ad hoc, and extremely rushed process designed to force through an appointment during the lame duck session,” former GAO senior associate general counsel Henry R. Wray said in a letter to HSGAC. Wray, a 30-year veteran of the agency, helped develop the 1980 law that established the comptroller general selection process.
“The law has been turned on its head with the president apparently specifying his choice for the commission to endorse rather than the other way around,” Wray wrote. “These perversions of the statutory process clearly reveal the real objective underlying the exercise: to convert the Comptroller General into an agent of the administration rather than an agent of Congress in order to stymie rather than ensure rigorous, objective oversight of the executive branch” (emphasis in the original).
Wray urged Paul to reconsider.
“Any Comptroller General who emerges from such a partisan, fractured, and legally dubious process will obviously lack broad-based credibility and thereby greatly diminish GAO and its usefulness to you as your watchdog agency. It’s hard to imagine anything more shortsighted and inimical to Congress’s interests as an institution.”
A coalition of bipartisan organizations and governmental experts likewise urged elected officials to follow the law, writing in their own letter that three prior comptrollers general received the support of all ten members of the commission, a tradition that should continue. They also questioned why Paul was rushing given that Brown is widely regarded as handling the job as acting head and that “there is no institutional emergency requiring an immediate appointment.”
“The Comptroller General must be of the highest caliber and have the confidence of members of both parties because this position leads the agency that serves Congress as an institution,” the groups wrote. “No President should nominate a candidate until Congress has undertaken the customary public search and bipartisan evaluation of candidates.”
The American Governance Institute’s Schuman, whose organization released both letters, said it’s unclear to him why members of both chambers “would want to cut their own throat when it comes to holding the executive branch accountable.”
But he noted that Trump’s government has engaged in multiple illegal rescissions and impoundments of congressionally appropriated funds, which the GAO has already investigated. The office has found multiple instances in which Trump’s policies are illegal and have otherwise hurt Americans, including investigations that found that Trump’s pocket rescissions are illegal, that his Environmental Protection Agency illegally withheld climate and environmental funding Congress had approved, and that his decision to fire hundreds of Department of Education workers left 43 million student loan borrowers without protection.
The Prospect in your inbox
Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.
No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.
The Budget and Impoundment Control Act of 1974 gives the GAO the power to sue the president over illegal rescissions, giving Trump and Vought all the motivation they need to install a crony at the agency. Only the comptroller general has this power, not outside recipients of funding, according to a federal court ruling last year. Since Dodaro left, the acting comptroller general has been reluctant to use this authority.
Schuman recommended that Democrats and Republicans alike remember that the GAO works for Congress and that anyone under consideration should have fidelity to protecting the legislative branch. They should decline to advance Ueland’s nomination and make clear to leadership that they must follow the legal process for filling the position.
“Are there enough institutionalist Republican members who are not particularly in love with the administration, that they are willing to tell their leadership that they don’t want this to go forward? That’s the underlying question and I think the answer is yes,” Schuman said, “but they have to hear from people.”
Paul did not respond to an email asking why he is not following the legally required process to fill the position.
