Read the top story of the day in your inbox. Sign up for the Daily Prospect newsletter here.

Last Tuesday morning, the U.S. Postal Service (USPS) Board of Governors convened for its fourth and final meeting of the year. Postmaster General David Steiner, who as the Prospect reported, is the former FedEx board member handpicked by Trump to succeed Louis DeJoy, acknowledged that the agency remains in dire straits.

Without swift congressional action, Steiner warned that the USPS “will need to make drastic changes” to prevent the agency from scaling back operations as it stares down impending financial ruin from the continued decline of physical mail, which has only accelerated due to higher prices and worsened service. At least for now, the USPS is planning to slash its post office footprint, and reduce certain mail services as soon as early next year.

Amber McReynolds, chair of the Board of Governors, offered an even bleaker outlook at the meeting. “Ultimately,” she said, “our fiscal cliff is here.”

The Prospect in your inbox

Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.

No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.

But lost in all the buzz surrounding the agency’s financial troubles was the torrential backlash against its passive implementation this August of a rule restricting mail-in voting. The USPS finalized that rule after a March executive order from President Trump directed them to do so.

One hour before the meeting, postal workers and voting rights advocates gathered in Washington, D.C., to demand that the USPS “pull the rule.” They argue that pending litigation should not prevent the agency from defying the president’s “illegal executive order,” let alone bar the USPS from taking a stand to preserve its neutrality. In fact, the USPS has the statutory authority to do that, so long as it follows federal rulemaking procedures.

In September, the Supreme Court blocked the Trump administration’s scheme to restrict mail-in voting for the midterm elections. The legal dispute, which is now destined to return to the lower courts until the high court provides a timetable for issuing a final ruling, is at the center of a case brought by the League of Women Voters of Massachusetts against Trump in U.S. district court.

“We secured a critical victory when a federal judge blocked key provisions of the rule, and the Supreme Court allowed those protections to remain in place through the November election,” said Jessica Jones Capparell, director of government affairs at the League of Women Voters. “That victory helped protect voters from unnecessary confusion … but our work is not finished.”

But this issue doesn’t have to rely on the courts; the Board of Governors could settle the matter by themselves.

THE BOARD OF GOVERNORS MEETS four times a year, but it only holds public comment at one of those meetings. This year, it opened the floor to public comment at the Tuesday meeting.

Among those to speak was Jonathan Smith, president of the American Postal Workers Union. He addressed Steiner directly. “Temporary relief is not a permanent solution,” Smith said, referring to the Supreme Court’s September ruling. Workers and advocates say that ruling leaves the door open to voter disenfranchisement come 2028—when Americans will decide who succeeds Trump as president.

In remarks prior to the meeting, Smith reminded the Board of Governors: “The world is watching you, history is watching you, and most of all, God is watching you. Do the right thing and rescind this rule.”

Congress established the USPS as an independent institution with a unique public-service mission after passing the Postal Reorganization Act of 1970. Patrick Pitts, president of the National Rural Letter Carriers’ Association (NRLCA), opened his remarks with a passage from the law, which outlined the agency’s “basic and fundamental obligation” to the American people. NRLCA represents 130,000 letter carriers who deliver mail to more than 53 million homes and businesses in rural communities nationwide.

“For elderly Americans, individuals with disabilities, and rural residents who live miles from the nearest polling place, voting by mail is simply not a convenience,” Pitts said. “It’s an essential means of participating in their democracy.”

The rule restricting mail-in voting runs counter to that obligation, advocates say. One such advocate is Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR), who calls himself the first U.S. senator to be elected by mail.

“I’ve warned from the start that Trump’s attempts to overhaul the Postal Service are an effort to suppress American voters. Any threat to free and fair elections is a threat to democracy. Protecting election mail has long been an important responsibility at USPS, and rescinding this rule is key to achieving that mission,” Wyden told the Prospect.

The 2026 elections saw the second-highest turnout rate in a midterm year since 1914. Americans cast 32.1 million mail-in votes this year, with voters of color helping carry the Democratic Party to victory (or astoundingly close to it) in key races across the country.

The Prospect in your inbox

Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.

No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.

“Voters made their voices heard, including millions who relied on mail voting to participate in our democracy,” Jones Capparell said. “This election reinforced something that we have known for decades: Vote-by-mail works. It’s safe, it’s secure, and it’s a reliable way for Americans to exercise their fundamental right to vote.”

Had the high court not blocked the Trump administration’s restrictions from taking effect for the midterm elections, undue chaos would likely have disrupted the otherwise safe and secure process of mail-in voting.

“Based on whistleblowers who came forward, we know that the system the Postal Service was planning to implement was highly flawed, would have created mass chaos, [and] could have resulted in tens of thousands of ballots being invalidated if there was one mistake on one barcode,” said Rep. James Walkinshaw (D-VA). “That’s why it is so important that the Board of Governors do the right thing and repeal this rule.”

The board had little to say about the election at the meeting, and made no move to rescind the rule. A spokesperson responding to questions from the Prospect said that the agency was unable to comment due to the pending litigation.

The Constitution gives states the power to run and oversee elections, not the federal government. Forcing postal workers to deny ballots to voters is a “dangerous proposition in the times that we’re living in,” said Smith. Not only does the rule threaten to undermine public confidence in the USPS, but it also could expose postal workers to public anger over missing ballots.

“We should not be spending time and money … trying to fix what’s not broken. It has worked, and it continues to work,” Smith said. “The Postal Service should not wait for more litigation to take action.”

James Baratta is a writing fellow at The American Prospect. He previously worked as a reporter at MandateWire from the Financial Times. His work has appeared in Truthout, Politico, and The Progressive. James is a graduate of Ithaca College and a life-long member of the Alpha Kappa Delta International Sociology Honor Society. He is currently based in New York City.