Read the top story of the day in your inbox. Sign up for the Daily Prospect newsletter here.
Donald Trump thought he could defy history in a midterm, despite the fact that midterms usually punish incumbent presidents.

He embraced the playbook of the Tea Party and the MAGA movement, which has repeatedly and successfully motivated its base and deeply divided the country. Championing the resentment of white men, he focused his contempt on the first Black president, Barack Obama, and then on the Mexico border, Haitian immigrants, and alleged Somali fraud. He attacked stupid political leaders who signed trade agreements that sold out American workers. And at his rallies, he attacked the “woke elites” who hate America and gave you “DEI.” He warned of Democrats defunding the police, siding with Muslim terrorists, and embracing transgender people.
The Prospect in your inbox
Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.
No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.
In the words of his new chief of staff, Stephen Miller, “our enemies cannot comprehend our strength, our determination, our resolve, our passion … We will prevail over the forces of wickedness and evil.”
But Trump’s policies were deeply unpopular and sent him over an electoral cliff that became steeper the longer he campaigned. Trump’s MAGA campaigning increased the determination of Democrats to vote, further alienated independents, disappointed Trump voters, and reminded working-class, young, Black, and Hispanic voters that Trump betrayed them.
The Election
Polls underestimated the size of the blue wave because the outcome was a moving target. State polls from YouGov and The New York Times showed nearly all states moving toward the Democrats. Trump broke all records on presidential disapproval, including the 52 percent who “strongly” disapproved of him. His approval ratings on key issues continued to move down as we hit Election Day and afterward. And when my firm Democracy Corps conducted our large election survey, 17 percent said they decided for whom to vote in the last week. Many more of those were considering the Democrat.
Our election survey was fielded online from October 29 to November 6 by YouGov Blue among registered voters who voted in the November general election. The base sample is 1,339 voters, but this includes added samples of 566 Black Americans, 564 Hispanic Americans, 397 Asian Americans, and 523 Jewish voters. It included 672 Democratic primary voters.
Democrats won the House with a margin of 14 points in the House and 9 in the Senate. Democrats were promising to reverse Trump’s policies and bring bold changes. Despite the damaged Democratic brand and relentless paid attacks, Democratic candidates in most states raised their personal standing, responded to attacks, showed where they differed with national Democrats, understood local issues, and attacked the oligarchs around Trump.
Voters chose the Democrat, our surveys showed, because of affordability across multiple areas: the cost of groceries, health care, housing, utilities, and gas; Trump policies that raised prices through tariffs, energy prices after Iran, and regulatory neglect that allowed the biggest corporations to raise prices; and Republican policies cutting Medicaid and subsidies for the Affordable Care Act. They also voted for Democrats because of immigration overreach by ICE, and because of Republicans cutting taxes for the billionaires surrounding the president.
Trump deeply alienated so many groups who relished punishing him in the election. He was supposed to be a president for the working class but surrounded himself with high-tech oligarchs. He relished firing prominent women and Black leaders, and women saw abolishing DEI as directed right at them. Failing to cut prices on day one hit the youngest the hardest. Turning ICE into a deportation machine destroyed Hispanic communities. And the Supreme Court allowing Republicans to abolish majority-Black districts was intended to reverse all the progress Black Americans had achieved in America.
The result was that group after group punched back and turned a blue wave into a tsunami.
Watch the role of the new voters in this election. These are voters who passed up voting for Biden and Harris. Two-thirds were working-class and women, and they supported Democrats by 40 points. Astonishingly, Democrats won working-class women under 50 years of age.
Fully 55 percent of the Trump defectors were either Hispanic or Black. They voted 70 percent and 90 percent for Democrats, respectively. They voted as an aggrieved group, with little difference between men and women.
Democratic analysts have longed for the trends of Obama’s first election, when we took over 40 percent of the white vote in battleground states. In this election, Democrats got to 48 percent of the House vote and nearly broke even. Democrats got 43 percent in the Senate races.
Trump won many prominent union endorsements in 2024 and took 60 percent of white union households. This year, Democrats won white union households with a small majority and lost them in the Senate with a similarly small majority, a major improvement over two years ago.
Independents usually swing a few points between parties. Trump won independents in 2024 by 7 points. But Trump’s MAGA playbook was so off-putting that Democrats won them this year with two-thirds of the vote.
Reverse Trump’s Policies
With their new majority, the Democrats have a mandate above all to tax visible billionaires and high-tech companies that embraced Trump and funded Republican campaigns. Almost 40 percent chose that option in our survey. Taxing them was particularly important for Democratic voters, union households, and working-class women under 50.
Then, 36 percent of voters want government to act against the monopolies that are driving up prices for food, health care, prescription drugs, and housing. Fully one-third support passing ethics reform for the Supreme Court and banning congressional stock trading. A similar bloc wants to restore the Affordable Care Act subsidies to lower health insurance premiums. And most of the elected members are also talking about raising the minimum wage as well.
The new voters—who are mostly women, working-class, and young—elevated the restoration of the monthly Child Tax Credit and Congress reversing the tariffs.

A big majority opposes what Trump is doing on climate change. About 80 percent of those who voted for a Democratic House embrace measures to prevent climate change. There is powerful support among both liberal and moderate Democrats.
And a small majority of the country, and a vast majority of the Democratic base, wants to hit back and defend the effort “to make America more diverse, equitable, and inclusive.” A stunning 60 percent of Democratic voters, Black, Gen Z, Jewish, and white working-class women under 50 strongly want America to be a more diverse and equal country.
The Continuing Brand Problem
Democrats made further gains in this election because many more voters thought they would do a better job on some issues in their wheelhouse. They were preferred to the Republicans by 35 points on handling “climate change, extreme weather and the energy transition”; by 21 points on “health care”; and by 20 points on “abortion.” New are the 25-point advantage on “presidents not being able to act as autocrats” and 16 points on “democracy.” The risk to democracy was indeed a factor in this election.
And this year, Democrats matched their vote margin for the first time on who does better for “working people.”
But Democrats are no more trusted than Republicans on which party has “common sense leaders” and “oppose extremists.” That is a huge warning sign about the scale of the Democrats’ brand problem.
While Democrats have made gains on all issues, Republicans are still more trusted on “immigration,” “defense and national security,” “crime,” and “the border.”
In fact, Democrats get more Fs than As on critical values, like “personal safety and security” and “citizens having priority over non-citizens.” Democrats got their lowest grades on “listening to you, not the elites.”
An intense majority 54 percent has cool feelings about the Democratic socialists.
It is difficult to compare candidates in different states running against different opponents. But Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed won his race by 7.0 points. With the average loss of 7.6 points for the president’s party, we could still be waiting for that race to be called, but for the anti-Trump wave.
What Changes for Democrats?
What changes do Democrats need to make to address the brand problem? Respondents in our survey want major changes on both addressing cultural issues and inequality, but about a quarter more choose changes in the former.
First, they say stop listening to the elites on gender as an identity and prioritizing transgender issues in sports, open borders, or defunding the police. They want Democrats to focus more on kitchen-table issues than cultural ones. I would add seeing America as exceptional.
And second, Democrats need to focus on big structural changes in the political economy. Those discontented with Democrats want to see them take up a working-class agenda that advances manufacturing, infrastructure, and transportation. They also want to see Democrats fight against the heightened inequality, where its national leaders too allowed the top 1 percent and high-tech billionaires to buy their seats in government.

Democratic candidates in key battlegrounds addressed both of these points through bold changes in their campaigns and won with impressive margins. Democrats will want to learn from the candidates who just won in Ohio, North Carolina, Georgia, and Texas.
Bold Policy Changes
It is hard to underestimate the strength of support for the new Congress to take bold action to address social and economic inequality, confront monopolies to help consumers, and tax the high-tech billionaires who dominate the economy and politics.
The highest level of support starts with the expanded monthly Child Tax Credit.
Over 70 percent give warm, and half very warm, responses to the higher monthly Child Tax Credit that gave “tax relief to poor, working and middle-class families with children.” The intense embrace is strongest with Black voters, independents, union households, white working-class women under 50 and, surprisingly, MAGA Republicans! Breaking out the amounts people received per child reminds people of its impact. Here, the most powerful response comes among new voters and Trump defectors. They are the women, working-class, Black and Hispanic, and young who shifted to the Democrats.
“Limiting big monopolies’ profits so as to reduce costs for consumers” gets two-thirds warm responses and half very warm. But the very warm jumps to well over 60 percent for working-class women under 50, union households, independents, and Democratic primary voters. Two-thirds of moderate Democrats are on board. They are incredibly strong supporters of taxing billionaires.
Republicans in Trouble
Voters hated the Republican campaign that gave them no reason to vote for Republicans, except for securing the border that was overwhelmed under Biden. Over three-quarters of MAGA Republicans cheered that message, but why was so much of Republican advertising devoted to the risk of transgender policies? Just 38 percent of MAGA Republicans thought that was a good reason to vote Republican.
Republicans are a divided party that is, nonetheless, dominated by the 56 percent who describe themselves as MAGA.
With the selection of Stephen Miller as chief of staff and Rep. Jim Jordan as minority leader in the House, and with embattled Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth still in office, expect Trump to double down on immigration, ICE abductions in communities, mass deportations, purges of DEI, and the continuing battle for white men.
If they do so, Republicans will continue to lose the country.
A Democratic Party for the Working Class
Despite the profound issues facing the Democratic Party, it emerged for the first time as an ascendant party and the party of the working class. That was evident in the new levels of support among America’s diverse working class and in being seen as the party battling for them.
Clearly, our candidates in Alaska, Kansas, Iowa, Ohio, North Carolina, Georgia, Mississippi, and Texas showed what it takes to win, but Democratic voters still question after this election whether Democrats have “common sense leaders” who “listen to them, not the elites.” We are still behind Republicans on crime, immigration, defense, and national security.
This survey provides a road map for Democrats to take bold steps and embrace bold policies to become a hegemonic party.
