This article was featured in the Daily Prospect newsletter. Sign up for it here.
“Pick another senator instead.” The stand-in who uttered those words helped Scott Colom become the first Black man to represent Mississippi in the U.S. Senate since Reconstruction, when Blanche Bruce, who was born into slavery, served one term. But here’s one interesting sidelight: Colom’s extremely effective attack on Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith for dismissing concerns about beef prices serves as a demonstration of how unpopular the logic of economists truly is.
Hyde-Smith’s comment that launched Colom’s ad campaign was that when beef prices are high, it’s reasonable to “pick another protein.” If one meat is too expensive, you can simply switch to a cheaper one, like chicken or pork, that fits within your family budget.
This idea of substitution is the basis for an alternative measurement of inflation favored by many economists, who make the case that higher prices don’t affect people quite as badly as assumed. It’s called the Chained Consumer Price Index, or chained CPI, and in the 2010s, the small army of Washington mandarins expressing deep concern about the national debt wanted to use this measurement to cut Social Security benefits. Chained CPI has also operated, as I wrote in 2020, as “a stealth cut to public-assistance programs and a stealth increase to middle-class taxes.”
Budget modelers and economists have proposed and implemented these changes quietly, in back rooms and in white papers, in ways known primarily to a small subset of wonks in Washington who track these matters. It was austerity under cover of spreadsheets. It certainly never came up in the context of a political campaign, exposed to the public for their assessment. But Hyde-Smith’s claim that people have “so many proteins to choose from” brought this idea of substitution, and implicitly the idea of playing down the impact of inflation since people can just choose something else, up for public scrutiny.
And it was so toxic that it helped a Democrat win in Mississippi.
CHAINED CPI’S BIGGEST MOMENT CAME during the “grand bargain” deficit reduction debates of the early 2010s. Using the chain-weighted index can save the government money or increase revenue, because, generally speaking, the chained CPI comes in lower than the more typical Consumer Price Index measurement. If you calculate Social Security’s cost-of-living adjustment using chained CPI, then that COLA will likely be lower.
Supporters say that chained CPI is merely a more accurate rendering of inflation. But it translated into a 0.3 percent annual benefit cut for Social Security recipients, and while that may sound small, the impact would grow over time, limiting lifetime payments by thousands of dollars.
The Prospect in your inbox
Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.
No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.
Several deficit commissions around this time, from Simpson-Bowles to Domenici-Rivlin, recommended chained CPI. And in 2013, President Obama offered it as part of a “grand bargain” on deficit reduction, something that was only averted when far-right Republicans refused to accept a slight tax increase as part of the package.
The Trump administration picked up on chained CPI. In his first term, the 2017 tax cut law applied chained CPI as the inflation index for tax brackets, the standard deduction, and the Earned Income Tax Credit, creating a regressive tax increase by eroding deductions and credits and pushing people into higher tax brackets. The wealthy are unaffected by this since they’re already in the highest tax bracket and itemize rather than use the standard deduction.
Trump’s team also proposed using chained CPI to calculate the annual adjustment to the federal poverty line, which would have reduced or cut assistance for millions of people. (Ultimately, that did not happen.)
STALWART SUPPORTERS OF CHAINED CPI TOOK ISSUE with the comparison between it and the comments that sunk Cindy Hyde-Smith’s Senate career. But it’s worth noting that the way government agencies talk about chained CPI invariably uses precisely the same analogy that Hyde-Smith used, as economist Mike Konczal pointed out.
In a 2013 publication, the Congressional Budget Office explained the use of chain-weighted indexes this way: “A common example involves hamburger and steak. If the prices of both items rise, consumers will shift their spending toward the one whose price rises by a smaller percentage.” Another way of saying that is that when one meat becomes too expensive, they’ll pick another protein.
Similarly, the Bureau of Labor Statistics, in explaining how it calculates the chained CPI, saying that it’s intended to account for this scenario: “If the price of pork increases while the price of beef does not, consumers might shift away from pork to beef.” The Congressional Research Service uses the same concept: “buying more chicken and less fish due to an increase in the price of fish compared with chicken from one month to the next.”
The deeper psychology here, and what voters rejected, is that when a policy problem arose, Hyde-Smith, parroting the mindset of economists, threw the problem back on the public, forcing them to adjust rather than dealing with the disruption to their needs and preferences. The logic is, approximately: You’re not doing as badly as you think, so pick another protein and quit your whining.
The Prospect in your inbox
Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.
No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.
When I asked economists about chained CPI, some were uncomfortable with comparing it directly to Hyde-Smith’s comments. “The chain-weighted price index captures the fact that people substitute and are therefore hurt less,” said Jared Bernstein, the former Obama and Biden administration economic official. But, he added, “the logic is actually that they’re no worse off in welfare or utility terms because they’re buying enough extra chicken (or whatever, using their savings from buying less beef) to hold utility constant.” His point is that chained CPI just accounts for the substitution, and averages things out so beef lovers aren’t worse off.
Marc Goldwein of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB), one of the biggest boosters of chained CPI, was indignant, saying that it doesn’t have a “welfare bias” because all the switching is “welfare-neutral.”
But who decides that? The point of the substitution being tracked by chained CPI is that people switch to a cheaper product. Even CRFB’s own chained CPI resource page acknowledges this. So who decides whether the cheaper product they switch to is “similar” to the one that’s become so expensive that the consumer must give it up? It seems like any reasonable analysis is that the substitution in some way leaves the consumer worse off.
Economists who dispute that are inserting their determinations of value ahead of a consumer’s individual preference. That’s functionally similar to Cindy Hyde-Smith saying any other protein is just as good as beef. And based on the election results, people reacted emotionally to that economist style of logic, in pretty universal ways.
Bernstein did agree that Hyde-Smith’s comments were unforgivable. “A politician saying they should substitute is offensive in precisely the way you say,” he said. “It’s totally saying shut up and stop complaining. So, the voters implemented their own substitution effect—they chose a better senator!”
Maybe the lesson is that thinking like an economist won’t get you anywhere with the public.
