This article was featured in the Daily Prospect newsletter. Sign up for it here.

We are now in a three-week sprint to see who will become the next Senate majority leader: current Democratic chief Chuck Schumer or his challenger Chris Van Hollen. Schumer and his allies are flooding the media with evidence provided mostly by anonymous sources claiming that there is no contest and the election is predetermined in his favor. But Van Hollen and even some voting members of the caucus dispute that, and the most careful whip count shows that the outcome is still in doubt.

But the Van Hollen–Schumer fight will shape more than the future; it will shape the present. Ten days after the scheduled December 1 leadership vote, stopgap government funding runs out for fiscal year 2027. The plan from appropriators was to follow on with another stopgap until March or April, giving the new Democratic majority a couple of months to settle in and pass a blitz of early policy before having to deal with the budget. But Van Hollen’s candidacy may blow up that strategy, because he’s staking much of it on denying further funding for the Iran war.

The Prospect in your inbox

Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.

No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.

What Van Hollen wants, along with a growing number of Senate Democrats from across the ideological spectrum—not just Bernie Sanders, but also mainstream liberal Sens. Tammy Duckworth (D-IL) and Michael Bennet (D-CO)—is a rider that would bar any appropriated money from being put toward hostilities in Iran. This was the way Democrats blocked funding for the bombing of North Vietnam and Cambodia in 1973.

“I think we need to use all our powers right now to end this illegal war against Iran,” Van Hollen told CNN’s State of the Union on Sunday. “And that means not one penny more. That’s been my position. That’s not the position of the current majority leader.”

Schumer, when asked, has said only that he’s working with incoming Appropriations Committee chair Sen. Patty Murray (D-WA) to find a solution before a government shutdown is triggered. He’s hinted at using the power of the purse to stop presidents from pursuing war, but he’s wary of triggering a government shutdown if Donald Trump doesn’t want his hands tied.

The war was a huge factor in the Democratic midterm victory this month, to the extent that even JD Vance blames it for the thumping. It led to the toxic combination of higher prices and enlarged corporate profits. Practically every Democrat ran on ending the war, and few of them would be able to dispute a high-profile maneuver to deny funding for it. Van Hollen shoved this issue to the front of the debate, and in many ways it represents the leadership fight itself: action vs. caution, fight vs. flight.

Voters seem to be clear on what kind of Democratic Party they want to see. An end-of-the-year stopgap fundraising bill in the midst of trimming the tree wasn’t destined to get a lot of attention. But Van Hollen has now made it impossible to ignore.

Of course, Republicans still control both chambers until next January and are likely to protect their president from impositions on his power. “If they make the budget … contingent upon us cutting and running in Iran, yeah, we’ll have a shutdown,” Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA) told Punchbowl News last week.

Deep down, the president may be happy to have his impulses blocked. Vance’s comments reinforce the predicament Trump finds himself in. Battle plans to resume airstrikes were reportedly drawn up before the elections, but the acknowledgment of the war’s impact on hobbling this presidency caused a rethink. The window for restarting operations is closing fast, and so far, Trump has refrained from attacks and publicly called any resumption “highly unlikely.” He’d clearly prefer Iran, which is under extreme economic strain, to come back to him begging for a resolution.

The problem is that Trump’s imagined leverage over Iran is predicated on the bombs he doesn’t want to drop. Congress denying funding for those bombs would ruin his semblance of a “do nothing and hope” strategy.

Therefore, a rider denying funds would likely produce a standoff. And a shutdown that spilled over into next year would be an immediate fire the incoming Democratic majority would need to put out, ruining a more calculated strategy of advancing bills addressing health care and affordability. Plus, federal employees who rallied to the side of Democrats would once again feel the most pain amid the impasse.

Yet this is an uniquely unpopular war, which Democrats vowed to stop. The scramble to find some justification for not working to stop it as soon as possible will have base voters getting those queasy feelings again about the feckless party leadership, in the middle of a leadership fight.

That’s particularly true for Schumer, given his history on both Iran and government funding fights. He failed to back Barack Obama on the deal that, were it still in place, would be stopping Iran from obtaining nuclear material today. And he waved through a seven-month funding deal at the height of the DOGE assault in March 2025, showing that he was not equipped to deal with a tyrant engaged in seizing the power of the purse for the executive branch.

It should be explained that the funding channel isn’t the only way to stop the war. Earlier this year, both the House and Senate passed a war powers resolution that directed Trump to end all military action against Iran. Two Republican senators changed their minds and reconsidered, but that doesn’t change the fact that the resolution passed, and because it was a concurrent resolution it does not require Trump’s signature.

There has never been a legal ruling on whether a concurrent resolution, and the War Powers Act itself, is legally binding. Congress would have to sue the president for failing to stop the war; Republicans are unlikely to do that and have the votes until the new Congress convenes to block any such action. But it could also be the case that any member could raise the matter and sue the president, or service members in Iran could sue on the grounds that Congress nullified the deployment.

As I wrote this summer, none of this has any precedent, and yes, the Supreme Court could just side with the executive, which is the default position of its Republican members. But failing to test out the law in court means that the War Powers Act is functionally unusable.

The Prospect in your inbox

Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.

No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.

There’s also a different possible avenue: the National Defense Authorization Act, typically a must-pass bill at the end of the year. A prohibition on war funding could be added to the NDAA, which needs 60 votes to pass, and which has a host of measures perceived as vital to defense hawks. Democrats may have more leverage on the NDAA than a government funding bill for these reasons (and more political space than a shutdown would, as it wouldn’t throw federal employees temporarily out of work), though denying funding at the appropriations level has stronger teeth. There are other pieces of the NDAA that Van Hollen and others want excised, like a provision intertwining the U.S. and Israeli militaries.

So Schumer has options at the end of the year. He could place the prohibition rider in the NDAA, or he could have an ally like Sen. Tim Kaine (D-VA), who introduced the original war powers resolution, put another one forward. That would have a chance at success; it did pass a Republican Senate before, and Sen.-elect Sherrod Brown (D-OH), who won a special election over Jon Husted in November, is scheduled to get sworn in during the lame-duck session, giving Democrats an additional vote.

I’m not sure this would satiate Van Hollen—or even Kaine, who supports using the power of the purse as well. Both would presumably argue for a belt-and-suspenders approach, with both a war powers vote to end the war and a rider to end the funding, wherever it may be placed. But in that event, Democrats would be bargaining over how to be maximally aggressive, not whether to be aggressive at all.

The looming 2028 presidential race and the majority leader election combine to push the caucus in the aggressive direction. And after two exasperating years and a big mandate granted by the voters, the knee-jerk reaction toward caution isn’t going to be viewed as acceptable. Even if Van Hollen loses, he may force the Iran issue into the open, where it’s much harder for Democrats to capitulate to Trump.

David Dayen is the executive editor of The American Prospect. He is the author of Monopolized: Life in the Age of Corporate Power and Chain of Title: How Three Ordinary Americans Uncovered Wall Street’s Great Foreclosure Fraud. He co-hosts the podcast Organized Money with Matt Stoller. He can be reached on Signal at ddayen.90.