Read the top story of the day in your inbox. Sign up for the Daily Prospect newsletter here.
In October, southwest Colorado saw some of its worst flooding since the United States Geological Survey put in stream gauges over a century ago. At Pagosa Springs, the San Juan River topped out at 11,200 cubic feet per second, while in Durango, the Animas River peaked at 13,000 cubic feet per second. Both figures are the highest since 1911. The tiny Mancos River, meanwhile, peaked at 5,170 cubic feet per second—almost six times the previous record.
The resulting damage was enormous. Hundreds of homes and businesses were inundated or destroyed entirely. The San Juan River flood coated much of Bluff, Utah, with mud that turned out to be heavily contaminated with E. coli bacteria, while upstream it washed out several sections of Highway 160, a critical east-west transport artery over the mountains. Anyone needing to get from the Durango area to Colorado Springs or Denver, or vice versa, currently must take a massive detour.
The Prospect in your inbox
Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.
No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.
The flooding was undoubtedly due to the “super” El Niño that is in progress, which may end up being the strongest ever recorded. This complex climate phenomenon has many varied effects: powerful waves and tides slamming the coast of Southern California, mild winters in the Northeast, and heavier precipitation in the typically arid Southwest. (Another one is the Pacific Ocean dumping incomprehensible amounts of heat into the atmosphere; 2027 will almost certainly be the hottest year ever recorded.)
The reason this El Niño is so strong, simply put, is climate change. And the costs are going to be astronomical.
So far, few Democrats are making the connection between climate change and rising costs for American families. On the contrary, as Robinson Meyer details, many of the more moderate candidates who won in the recent midterm election went the opposite direction, abandoning Joe Biden’s climate and renewables focus for Barack Obama–style “all of the above” energy rhetoric. That’s intended to signal a desire to lower electricity bills. But massive and frequent calamities like what transpired in Colorado obliterate any benefits from increases in the energy supply mix.
The Democratic Party has settled on “affordability” as one of their core political topics. It registers as one of the most important in polls, it was a constant refrain in the last election, and presidential contenders are already talking about it as part of their 2028 strategy—but not much with respect to climate. It’s bizarre because climate policy is one of the few areas where affordability benefits are readily available. Neglecting these potential tangible victories is not only a short-term mistake, but a medium-term disaster.
Donald Trump demonstrates the political danger of affordability politics. It is easy to run against an unpopular incumbent by promising to reverse price increases, as he did in 2024. But when you fail to do it, the people turn against you. And some of the more high-profile affordability policies are unlikely to have an immediate impact, putting those politicians who advocate for them precisely in Trump’s shoes. Trying to cut home prices through some reform of the zoning and permitting process, for instance, will take years.
Moreover, the only way to reduce all prices at once—what particularly consumerist Americans seem to want—would be to create a severe economic depression. Prices fell by about a quarter during the Great Depression, at the price of 25 percent unemployment, mass bankruptcies, and a collapsed banking system.
The affordability argument for climate policy, by contrast, is simple and not nearly as harmful. On the one hand, as noted above, climate disasters are getting worse every year, and are much more expensive than previously estimated. In addition to wildly unseasonable flooding, just the recent episodes of suffocating wildfire smoke blowing down from Canada are estimated to cost more than every previously measured climate expense put together.
If the United States does not do its part to slash emissions—and ideally help pressure the rest of the world to do the same—American towns and cities are going to suffer increasingly expensive weather disasters. There are few things less affordable than your house or business being destroyed. It doesn’t get more “kitchen-table issue” than preventing your actual kitchen table from being washed downstream along with the rest of your house.
It is admittedly difficult to establish in the public mind the financial benefit of something like a flood or a fire not happening. But on the other hand, as I have pointed out over and over for years at this point, renewable energy is now the cheapest form of electricity on the planet. Spain and Australia prove that if you add enough wind, solar, and battery capacity to drive expensive gas peaker plants out of the market, plus enough grid upgrades to transmit the electricity where it needs to go, you enjoy lower or even declining prices.
If people can be induced to switch to an EV that can be charged at home or at work, the affordability benefits compound. A somewhat higher up-front cost is compensated by dramatically cheaper fueling and maintenance costs. The up-front cost is dropping even with the expiration of the federal purchase rebate. Some newer EV models are under $30,000, with more on the way, and used ones are cheaper still. The economic benefit is strengthened still further by price security, as gas and diesel prices are set on the world market and are prone to sudden large increases, as we have seen.
Rooftop solar can cut costs as well, as people offset their electricity consumption or are paid for what they export to the grid. Home battery storage can cut costs even further. You can capture and use your solar production directly—thus avoiding strain on the grid—or in places with variable time-of-use rates, you can arbitrage electricity prices and smooth out power consumption at the same time. Better yet, the batteries can be networked together into a virtual power plant that will sell power to the grid whenever it is needed, making a tidy profit.
Add in some heat pump incentives for HVAC systems and water heaters and clothes dryers, all of which are dramatically more efficient than traditional electric appliances, and families can reduce their electric bills and/or cancel their natural gas or heating oil service entirely, saving yet more.
The Prospect in your inbox
Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.
No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.
Home batteries can also save lots of money protecting against grid instability caused by climate change. I experienced this personally this summer when a severe climate change–fueled heat wave knocked the power out for more than 24 hours, but thanks to solar and batteries I had installed myself, we were able to keep the refrigerator and a window AC unit running the whole time. That probably saved $500 in food right there, or something like a tenth of the cost of my entire solar-battery system.
This basic formula of rooftop solar and home batteries plus electrifying all household energy needs requires a lot of up-front investment, but it pays off handsomely over five to ten years, and even more as time passes. Australia is further along this path than any other nation, and it is proving to be enormously popular.
It’s a mystery why this extremely obvious argument is not yet conventional wisdom. I suspect this is because climate policy is still being metabolized in America’s collective political unconscious as self-flagellatory, hair-shirt environmentalism, like when earnest liberals buy expensive vegan food at Whole Foods, when in reality it is about elementary self-interest.
It’s also true that somebody has to pay those up-front costs, even if they are coming down, and that gives climate policy opponents—like the people who sell fossil fuels—a great argument to make about renewables and electrification being more expensive, when over time the situation is exactly the opposite.
But the latest inflation report is clear: Prices are increasing in large part because Donald Trump’s war on Iran has jacked up the price of oil. It is senseless to respond to that affordability problem by saying we need to suspend the gas tax, as Sen.-elect Annie Andrews (D-SC) did in her campaign platform. We should instead stop burning gas entirely, so we can save money.
