If ever there were an inexact science—even a particularly inexact art—it would be plumbing the joint statements of national leaders to determine which of the particulars they actually meant. In surveying the joint communiqué released this morning by the three confabbing presidents who’d met in Shenzhen—China’s Xi, Russia’s Putin, and our own Trump—we found, amid the usual boilerplate, one shared and deeply held conviction.
The communiqué consisted of four briefly stated points. The credibility of two were certainly plausible. I don’t doubt that they all thought that nuclear war was a bad idea. I similarly believe their joint commitment to turning out and refining more petroleum, the fate of the planet notwithstanding. The third point—reforming the United Nations—was so vague that it didn’t amount to anything in particular (though the presidents’ three nations are all permanent members of the Security Council, whose powers and structure they may wish to enhance, but in different ways to different ends).
Today on TAP
This story first appeared in our free Today on TAP newsletter, a weekday email featuring commentary on the daily news from Prospect reporters.
No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for Today on TAP, our weekday afternoon newsletter.
But it’s the fourth point, and only the fourth point, that conveys a ring of existential certitude and sincerity. It states, in full:
The three heads of state recognized that the principle of state consent and respect for immunities of State officials are of paramount importance, and concurred that the International Criminal Court and other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction.
This resounded with the clarity of a felon demanding a get-out-of-jail-free card. Established in 2002 in reaction to the recent atrocities in Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia, the Court was mandated by the Rome Statute, enacted by 120 U.N. members, to prosecute genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and aggression. Among the nations that did not vote to ratify the statute and have not agreed to the court’s legitimacy are the U.S., China, and Russia (as well as India, Israel, and a smattering of others).
As none of the three nations whose leaders met around Shenzhen’s roundtable are party to the statute, any ICC actions against those nations, their leaders, and their soldiers can’t be enforced within those nations’ borders. However, the nations (now 125) that are statute signatories are supposed to arrest such leaders and soldiers, if the ICC has put out arrest warrants against them, when they journey to those signatory nations. A number of Russian officials, most prominently Putin, have active ICC arrest warrants against them for war crimes in Ukraine. Previously, the ICC investigated possible war crimes by U.S. soldiers in Afghanistan, but I don’t believe any arrest warrants were issued, and that investigation is no longer active.
It’s no stretch of the imagination to think that not only Putin but Xi and Trump as well are concerned about this arrest warrant business. The Trump administration’s actions in Venezuela and Iran, as well as against boats on the high seas, could well become ICC targets, while any Chinese invasion of Taiwan would present the ICC with a no-brainer. In any event, Trump and Xi certainly don’t want their travel curtailed as Putin’s has been (restricted as it is to the likes of Mongolia, Belarus, Kazakhstan—and, mercifully, China).
As I write, the text of the joint communiqué has been released by both Russia and China, but not yet by the United States. The text I linked to and quoted was China’s translation into English of the text they posted online. It’s possible that the text that Trump’s people are working on includes asides on Putin’s butt and assertions that this is the greatest four-point tripartite communiqué ever devised by three great and very tough leaders, possibly the greatest and toughest leaders of all time, though Trump, of course, is even greater and tougher than Putin and Xi, who are really tough, but Trump is the toughest ever—just ask Dana White and Hulk Hogan. (What? No, keep Hulk in the text.)
We eagerly await the Trump version (the greatest and most definitive ever).
