×
BUSH's IDEA OF A FAIR JUDGE. Via Matt, an excellent summary of the record of Leslie Southwick, the latest Bush Circuit Court nominee whose primary qualification is a slavish devotion to business interests. Particularly remarkable is the case of Richmond v. Mississippi Dep't of Human Services, in which the Court of Appeals of Mississippi (in an opinion joined by Southwick) upheld the state's decision to overrule a Department of Human Services decision to fire an employee who used a racial slur against another employee. The state's decision is subject to review, and cannot be "arbitrary or capricious." So what were the findings that justified overriding the decision of DHS? As the dissent notes, here was the argument:
(1) DHS overreacted;(2) the remark was made in an open meeting with an atmosphere of give and take;(3) the term "good ole nigger" was not a racial slur; (4) calling Varrie Richmond a "good ole nigger" was equivalent to calling her "teacher's pet."Arguing that these justifications for overriding the DHS' decision to fire the employee strain credulity is the least that can be said. ("Teacher's pet?") They were, however, good enough for Southwick, despite his typical position that employers should normally have the virtually unlimited discretion to fire employees. Southwick is not good enough for a seat on the federal circuit courts, and the Democrats should not consider even letting him out of committee. Although Supreme Court appointments get the vast bulk of the attention, other federal appointments matter a great deal, and the more appointments Bush gets to make the more ambiguous Supreme Court precedents that will be applied by judges who make John Roberts look like Thurgood Marshall. --Scott Lemieux