After reading the Majikthise-Dadahead exchange on Paul Hackett, I'm not especially happy with the arguments of either side. I haven't yet decided who I want to win the Ohio Senate primary, though I'm leaning towards Brown. (Like everybody else, I donated to Hackett's House race this year.) Below, I'm going to criticize both of their arguments, and present the state of the debate as I see it. I'm open to being convinced, but I don't think the arguments given so far are convincing.