A NYT column on the impact of illegal immigrant workers on the economy framed the question as:
"To some people, they represent a black-market work force that is lowering the wages of legal immigrants and native-born Americans. To others, they are an essential part of several big industries. What’s the truth?"
Well it seems to me that for the first to be true the second would also have to be true. Suppose that illegal immigrants were only a peripheral part of a small number of industries. It would be difficult to make a case that they were having a substantial effect on wages. If illegal immigrants have a big effect on wages, then it must be because they play a large role in the economy.
As the article rightly points out, many industries would have to be reorganized if they did not have access to a large flow of immigrant workers. I'm not sure why anyone should care. (Isn't that what happens all the time in a capitalist economy?) Near the end, the article presents an ominous warning from a public policy professor that, without illegal immigrants "over all, the U.S. would be poorer.” That might be true, and those hiring nannies, housecleaners, and garderners would suffer the most. But those who might fill some of these jobs if the wages rose by 50 percent (recognizing that many fewer would be hired), might not care too much that the country as a whole is poorer.
I’m writing to you today with a sense of urgency that I haven’t felt since I began my journalism career. As executive editor of The American Prospect, I’ve witnessed firsthand how independent journalism serves as a crucial bulwark against the erosion of our democratic institutions. Today, that role is more vital than ever. Can you step up today and show your support?
The winds of authoritarianism are blowing stronger. We’re seeing alarming signs of a coordinated effort to silence critical voices and undermine the very foundations that support progressive causes. As Bob Kuttner presciently wrote in our August 2024 issue, a weaponized IRS could attack the very foundations of the progressive movement. We need readers to step up and help us dig in for the long haul.
We’re falling behind in our spring fundraising campaign, and with so much at stake we can’t afford to come up short. If you value fearless, independent journalism that holds the powerful accountable and defends democracy, now is the time to step up. The American Prospect depends on reader support to stay in the fight. Pitch in today and help us close the gap. Please consider making a donation today.
–David Dayen, Executive Editor
Copyright 2025 | The American Prospect, Inc. | All Rights Reserved
