Is There An Actual Crisis in U.S. Education?

Over at the American Journalism Review, The Washington Post's Paul Farhi has a much-needed critique on how the "education in crisis" narrative cropped up in journalism across the country. Farhi, a veteran education reporter, notes how widespread the idea of school failure has become, pointing out that in January alone, there were at least 544 stories about "failing schools" (He doesn't even mention the report from the Council on Foreign Relations arguing education has gotten so bad it constitutes a national security risk). While the stories tend to carry similar messages—in particular that self-proclaimed education reformers are helping to stop the downward spiral—these conclusions don't square with all the data. Elementary and middle school students have improved consistently in the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study, and matriculation to higher education has never been higher. "All told," Farhi writes, "America's long-term achievements in education are nothing short of stunning."

The point is not that education is perfect, but that the journalistic coverage paints an inaccurate portrait of where we're failing. "[R]ather than evidence of a 'crisis,'" Farhi states, "this new data may simply have laid bare what was always true but never reported in detail."

The article only hints at the obvious policy implications such coverage produces. It's easy to assume that things were oh-so-much better in the glory days of the 1950s. Of course, unmentioned in this fable is that thousands of black children were forced to go to all but unfunded schools with little oversight, few actually went to college and women were often limited in their course options and educational goals. Those with special needs were sometimes simply rejected from schools.

If you believe we simply know more about the system's weaknesses now, that means we don't have to re-do the entire educational system. If traditional public schools have redeeming values and even those struggling can be saved, efforts to implement school choice seem less necessary. Instead, it would seem like we should invest in building curriculum that encourages critical thinking skills, rather than fill-in-the-bubble testing to make sure students understand basic facts. We could trust educators to implement their efforts to improve.

If one believes the data shows that schools are getting worse, it brings a bevy of different policy goals. Assumptions that teachers are suddenly much less competent and education is awful has prompted punitive policies aimed at weeding out the failures in the system. Furthermore, while many education "reformers" look to improve the options for poor and minority students, they're sometimes partnering with those who would like to see education killed off in favor of cheaper free-market systems like vouchers or for-profit charter schools, approaches that have yet to yield superior results. While the factions have different motivations, the partnership has led to more school budget cuts across the country while states and the feds create higher stakes by demanding more test results. 

If anything is likely to cause a crisis, starving schools of funds while promoting for-profit alternatives seems like it might be a good start.

 

Comments

You may have a point. However, saying that Education in this country is adequate because more students are matriculating into college is simply misleading. More students are matriculating into college because:

1. Anyone can go as there are colleges that will take anyone with a Diploma or GED and a pulse. Colleges will do this to get a piece of the non-dischargable Federal Student Loan pie.

2. "Credential Inflation". Employers are now demanding College (and even Grad School) degrees for jobs that don't actually require that much education. They are doing this simply because they can because of reason #1.

All in all this means that people get jobs they could have done without a degree, only now they have a smug employer and a ton of debt.

Furthermore, while many education "reformers" look to improve the options for poor and minority students, they're sometimes partnering with those who would like to see education killed off in favor of cheaper free-market systems like vouchers or for-profit charter schools, approaches that have yet to yield superior results.

Interesting use of the word "education" in this paragraph. Can children only learn in schools that are staffed and operated by employees of the State or local school districts? How is education killed off if kids leave such schools but go to charter schools or parochial schools? Vouchers and charter schools will reduce the number of children in State schools - but they don't kill off education, they just change where it occurs. I don't see where you are asserting that charter schools are less effective than State schools, after all.

If anything is likely to cause a crisis, starving schools of funds while promoting for-profit alternatives seems like it might be a good start.....

If the number of students in State-operated and staffed schools are reduced, why shouldn't the amount of funding going to such schools also be reduced? And if for-profit schools are able to educate children to the same extent as State-operated schools do and the children's parents are satisfied with the results (note that if they're not they can pull the kids out) and do it cheaper, why should we continue to have the State run schools? How is such a change a crisis?

The purpose of public education is to educate the public at public expense so that everyone can get an education regardless of whether they can personally afford it. It is not to provide State jobs to teachers and administrators or to build and operate school buildings. If private for-profit and not-for-profit organizations can both provide at least equally effective education, do it cheaper and give parents more choices and control over their kids (you are pro-choice, I presume) why would we continue to have the State operate schools?

Currently most people are seeking, Christmas wallpapers
the backdrop that's greater basic illustration and also here is the logic behind, new year Wallpapers why the 3d images wall picture set-up is attaining with world-wide acknowledgement everyday.

You need to be logged in to comment.
(If there's one thing we know about comment trolls, it's that they're lazy)

Connect
, after login or registration your account will be connected.
Advertisement