This article was featured in the Daily Prospect newsletter. Sign up for it here.

DENVER – Basking in the afterglow of a historic midterm victory, Democratic consultants, campaign staff, media figures, and candidates are all trying to channel the energy and chart a path forward. These operatives are flocking to podcasts, op-ed columns, and conferences to put their own stamp on the big win as an affirmation of their ideas. What’s Next, a key post-election gathering held in Denver, was billed as an effort to bring together “the people who will write the party’s next chapter.” I went to listen and ask questions about what was being said.

The logo of the Revolving Door Project: a revolving door

What’s Next was presented by Majority Democrats, the brainchild of venture capitalist and Obama administration alumnus Seth London. Following Kamala Harris’s loss in the 2024 presidential election, London drafted a memo advocating for “market-friendly moderation” and the creation of a party within the party explicitly modeled on the Democratic Leadership Council, which jettisoned the party’s New Deal roots and turned it into a neoliberal husk. Majority Democrats PAC is a dark money–fueled influence network bankrolled by several Wall Street and Silicon Valley tycoons, some with deep ties to the AI hustle. The roster of billionaire donors funding the project includes hedge fund titan Stephen Mandel and his wife Susan, financiers like Mark Heising and ex-Republican Michael Bloomberg, Netflix co-founder and school privatization enthusiast Reed Hastings, media mogul James Murdoch and his wife Kathryn, and Nvidia board member Tench Coxe and his wife Simone.

The Prospect in your inbox

Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.

No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.

The convening provided a platform for dozens of public figures, many of whom are not themselves members of Majority Democrats, to speak. Almost everyone described affordability and corruption as pressing priorities, and a handful called for tackling deeper, underlying problems like outrageous levels of inequality. That said, there was relatively little talk of taxing the rich and even less about expanding unions.

The event was “highly curated and very scripted,” progressive political strategist Doyle Canning told the Prospect. There “seemed to be a consensus … on the importance of relief for working-class Americans,” she added, “without a willingness to take on the billionaire class.”

Canning is the author of a recent Movement Voter Project report on reforming the Democratic Party, which is based on more than 100 interviews with stakeholders. She came to What’s Next to hear what self-styled leaders had to say about the party’s future.

“The cognitive dissonance was palpable,” said Canning. “Some of the most moderate standard-bearers in the party” were “championing almost a sanitized version of Bernie 2016.” On the one hand, “this is progress for progressives that our message has become mainstream,” Canning continued. “And yet, without the material side of the power struggle that must ensue, you know, it will continue to be empty rhetoric, which will continue to sort of damage the already distrustful relationship that working-class voters have with the Democratic Party.”

At a time when the Democratic Party’s center of gravity appears to be shifting left, What’s Next felt like a concerted effort, carried out by a formidable centrist political operation, to rechannel anti-system energy in a direction more acceptable to wealthy elites.

Democratic Sen.-elect James Talarico of Texas
Democratic Sen.-elect James Talarico of Texas addresses conference attendees. Credit: David Zalubowski/AP Photo.

This was especially the case when 38-year-old Rep. Jake Auchincloss of Massachusetts, previously a registered Republican and now chair of Majority Democrats, tried to portray his preferred grab bag of market-friendly and socially “moderate” policies as the “common sense” necessary to win hard races. Things were a bit more ambiguous when Sen.-elect James Talarico of Texas, a populist member of Majority Democrats, said that we must “unrig this economic system that only benefits the top 1 percent” and “unrig this political system so no billionaire, no trillionaire can buy our elections.”

This may reflect a difference between candidates who need to win tough races on populist platforms and devoted anti-leftists like Auchincloss, who has a safe blue seat (he even ran unopposed in 2024) but urges a more moderate message.

Although Majority Democrats couldn’t fully rein in the populist messaging at their own conference, I’m skeptical that the group’s corporate benefactors will support serious attempts at downward redistribution and getting money out of politics. The Murdochs, for example, are actively trying to inculcate what they call “radical centrism,” which Politico described as “engineering a temperamentally moderate, pro-business politics more to their liking.”

“I walked away being very confused as to what [Majority Democrats’] cohesive policy vision is,” Daniel Lobo-Lewis, co-founder of the Political Integrity Project, an anti-corruption advocacy group, told the Prospect. “Vague posting city” is how he described it to me.

The vagueness appeared to be infecting the entire party in Denver. “Cory Booker goes on stage and gives a very rousing speech,” Lobo-Lewis said. “But what does he call for? Like, health care you can afford. What does that mean? No one really knows.”

Real Economic Populism

It’s a testament to the Democratic Party’s left wing that a growing share of its leaders are decrying the cost-of-living crisis as endemic to our rigged economy and, to a lesser degree, denouncing the robber barons responsible. Newcomers are running on more explicitly populist platforms. That’s why some have argued that the left—especially Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani—“won” the midterms by changing the terms of political debate.

Some moderate commentators are pretending that they’ve supported this populist strategy all along. They are trying to claim credit for the blue wave even after trashing the “Fighting Oligarchy” tour, where Sanders and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) laid the groundwork for the anti-Trump backlash. It should be noted that Bernie and AOC are stalwarts of the “activist left,” which Majority Democrats’ website lists as a problem alongside the “gerontocratic establishment” and the “MAGA right.”

What’s Next revealed a tension between the Democratic Party’s willingness to vaguely speak about plutocratic power and its capacity to genuinely challenge it. Lots of featured speakers deployed some populist rhetoric, but it was far less clear where most of them stood on populist policies. “Vagueposting city” is how Lobo-Lewis described it to me.

That was not the case, however, with Rep. Ro Khanna (D-CA), whose speech stood out for its directness and specificity.

The longtime progressive, widely expected to run for president in 2028, called for “standing up to private insurance and drug companies and delivering Medicare for All.” He called for “standing up to the defense contractors and cutting a $1 trillion bloated Pentagon budget,” including putting an end to foreign wars as well as military aid to Israel. He demanded “a wealth tax on the billionaires who are the economic royalists of our time,” which would raise trillions of dollars for “free college, free child care, fully funded IDEA [Individuals with Disabilities Education Act] in public schools” and a “Marshall Plan” to invest in America. Khanna advocated for a $25 minimum wage and denounced the genocide in Gaza. He also expressed solidarity with immigrants and said, “We will abolish ICE.”

Demonstrators hold signs reading, "Abolish billionaires"
People demonstrate near the conference in Denver, November 13, 2026. Credit: Kenny Stancil.

To “reach disaffected independent and MAGA voters who want change” requires “being uncompromised,” Khanna added. “This is actually how we win.” The speech, which garnered some of the loudest applause at the convention, melded substantive economic populism with a defense of socially liberal values.

In contrast to Khanna, Majority Democrats adviser Lis Smith, a lead consultant on Pete Buttigieg’s 2020 presidential campaign, told Fox News during the conference that it would be the “height of hubris” for the party to push for Medicare for All and abolishing ICE. Her reasoning was that the Democratic candidates who won U.S. Senate races in Iowa, Texas, and Kansas—Josh Turek, James Talarico, and Adam Hamilton, respectively—didn’t campaign on those supposedly “far-left” proposals.

The appeal to a big-tent ethos, undercut by a lack of concrete commitments, is a hallmark of the Lis Smith canon. Prior to working for Buttigieg, she played a pivotal role advising the Independent Democratic Conference in New York’s state Senate, working actively to split the tent and keep Democrats from having a majority.

I asked political strategist and Mamdani adviser Morris Katz, who spoke on a panel, about efforts by Majority Democrats’ leaders to make certain policies taboo. “The idea that the toxic source that drives down the Democratic brand is Medicare for All rather than the influence of corporate money,” he told me, “is absurd and undercut by any polling data.”

Competing Theories of Electoral Success

It’s useful to consider some of the arguments being made about why Democrats were electorally successful in 2026, including in places they’ve struggled to win for decades. Such debates are important insofar as they shape the Democratic Party’s strategy moving forward.

Lakshya Jain, director of political data at The Argument, took a jab at the left when he argued during his What’s Next presentation that moderate Democratic candidates “outperformed” their progressive counterparts, while acknowledging that these margins were smaller than they’ve ever been—an outcome he attributed to the fact that all Democrats focused on addressing the cost of living. But his entire case is premised on a faulty “wins above replacement” (WAR) model that treats elections in a vacuum where ideology is the only important variable and running up the score in safe districts is an imperative.

This pernicious argument is designed to help centrists exert ideological discipline on the Democratic Party’s left flank, whether it loses or wins by “not enough.” But different wings of the party pursue distinct strategies depending on local context. In a safe blue seat, Katz told the Prospect, “we don’t need someone … to have their specialty be overperformance.” Rather, “we need someone … to be the best fucking Democrat they can possibly be, and that’s their goal,” he added, citing the latest crop of Justice Democrats as an example.

The Prospect in your inbox

Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.

No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.

“The whole point of a big-tent party is for it to be a big tent,” said Katz. “You see a lot of folks who want to pull a tent over big enough that, like, you can spank your kids, but not big enough that you can put your body on the line to protect your community from ICE,” he continued, alluding to political strategist Adam Jentleson’s surprising recent advice on how to broaden the Democratic Party’s appeal. “It’s frustrating to see the … sliver of the party that’s in safe blue seats not be given the same right or leeway to be able to have different views,” said Katz.

After a panel we both attended, I asked Pennsylvania state Sen. Nikil Saval, who was just re-elected, to explain his thoughts on the nationwide blue wave. Saval cited several converging factors: As Trump’s unprovoked war on Iran hurt working-class living standards, Big Tech executives got even richer thanks in part to favors from the White House, and data centers made this dynamic of worsening inequality a localized reality. “Democrats spoke pretty consistently to fighting this system of corruption and fighting the fact that billionaires control our economy,” said Saval. To the extent there was deviation from this, it was due to regional factors, Saval said, as with Talarico, who “ran a very progressive economic campaign that also was … supportive of, to some degree, the oil and gas industries.”

Saval rejected the idea that winning required throwing vulnerable people under the bus. “The focus on material conditions didn’t necessarily mean that Democrats … abandoned their commitment to support” those enduring discrimination, said Saval. “We have plenty of candidates who won competitive races who were supportive” of trans youth, for instance, and the election of Scott Colom, the first Black senator in Mississippi since Reconstruction, shows the “tremendous legacy of civil rights and … organizing for racial equality within that state,” he added.

What’s key is that unlike Republicans, said Saval, “Democrats had in many places established credibility on the major issues that mattered to Americans.”

Faux Economic Populism

Auchincloss occupies one of the country’s safest blue seats. Yet the Majority Democrats chair used his time on stage to promote a consultant-crafted version of populism. “Voters rejected bad ideas on Election Day, and now it’s our turn to do the same,” said Auchincloss. “We need to let go of three kinds of bad ideas. The ones that defy common sense, the ones that run on inertia, and most urgently, the ones that ignore supply and demand.”

These nebulous talking points elicited a less enthusiastic crowd response than Khanna despite having home-field advantage.

The one area where Auchincloss has taken a populist stand involves pharmacy benefit managers, which he described as “the middlemen owned by health insurance corporations” that squeeze independent pharmacists. He’s introduced several bills on this, including one with Sens. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and Josh Hawley (R-MO) that would ban PBMs from owning pharmacies, an initiative that led CVS to pretend to break itself up on Election Day.

But most of the speech was rooted in market-friendly orthodoxy. “Voters were clear. Make life less expensive,” he said. “That means make markets work for the middle class.” How? According to Auchincloss, scrapping rent control will unleash housing supply and drive down prices, and passing “permitting reform” will lower utility bills. This was not the only allusion to “abundance”-inspired policymaking at the conference. Deregulation is a corporate-friendly alternative to real solutions like decommodification and direct public provision of housing and clean energy.

Auchincloss celebrated entrepreneurship, homeownership (the contradiction between real estate appreciation and increasingly unaffordable housing wasn’t mentioned), and meritocracy. He bemoaned the national debt, complained about pandemic school closures and the more recent cancellation of honors class, and endorsed beefed-up border security.

“Democrats, this is the moment to challenge and cast off these bad ideas and embrace the best and most radical one we ever had,” said Auchincloss. “Equal opportunity for all and special privileges for none.” Again, this hardly challenges the neoliberal status quo.

It pales in comparison to Khanna’s legitimately populist vision, which channels the legacy of Franklin Delano Roosevelt and the New Deal. “This moment demands a Democratic Party that, like FDR, has absolute clarity about an affirmative role of government,” said Khanna.

If anything, some speakers were contemptuous of government. The aforementioned Jentleson is founder and president of the Searchlight Institute, a think tank closely aligned with Majority Democrats in terms of shared funders and worldview. During his speech, he hinted at the coming release of “an agenda that meets Americans’ demands for big change, while reflecting the complexity with which they view the world.” The top item on that agenda, according to Jentleson’s presentation? “DOGE Done Right.”

Adam Jentleson onstage with "DOGE Done Right" projected above him
Adam Jentleson onstage at the What’s Next conference. Credit: Screenshot/Majority Democrats.

There’s certainly a way to balance budgets that involves ending contractor profiteering, drastically reducing military spending, and collecting the taxes that are owed. But the nation’s single largest employer, which has a widely unionized workforce and provides invaluable, and often lifesaving, services to the public, doesn’t deserve scorn. The Trump administration’s Federal Aviation Administration debacle, which stranded some attendees in Denver, exemplifies the need for more and better government, not less.

DOGE Done Right was followed by a “Security for All” agenda featuring “secure borders and safe neighborhoods.” Then an “American Security Guarantee” based on these three pillars: “health security,” “wage security,” and “job security.”

I suppose this is the kind of vague “populism” that’s palatable to the ruling class.

The Coming Fight

Despite an emerging consensus around the need to confront the cost-of-living crisis, there’s far less agreement about how to do that effectively. The elephant in the room is that pursuing a robust economic populist agenda would conflict with the interests of billionaires, including those who back Majority Democrats and their allies.

Still, as Lobo-Lewis noted, “the primary voters will decide” in 2028, regardless of Majority Democrats’ billionaire-backed attempt at containment. “I think [voters are] not going to be in favor of the people that are wishy-washy and constantly change their thinking on these things.”

I asked Saval if he’s concerned about an entity like Majority Democrats exerting so much influence over the party’s future direction. “It worries me when the major issues shaping the party are not being driven by working-class voters who ought to be the base of this party,” he told me.

MAGA’s right-wing “populism” was proven fraudulent and rejected by voters. If Democrats’ nascent populist turn isn’t genuine, the electorate will notice. Are Democrats going to take on corporate villains and fight for this country’s working-class majority, or are they going to tinker around the edges of the status quo in a way that preserves the interests of big business? They can’t do both.

“If Democrats do not deliver immediate, tangible benefits to working-class people,” political consultant David Shor warned during his What’s Next talk, “they are going to turn against us the same way that they turned against Donald Trump.”

Kenny Stancil is a senior researcher at the Revolving Door Project.