Read the top story of the day in your inbox. Sign up for the Daily Prospect newsletter here.

Today marks the release of Grand Theft Auto 6, the culmination of a 13-year video game development odyssey and the most expensive piece of entertainment ever created, with an almost unfathomable estimated budget of between $1 and $2 billion. The reviews are absolutely glowing, but gamers who plunk down between $80 and $100 to buy GTA6 are sure to be underwhelmed at first. Because there’s nothing inside the box but a download code.

Rockstar Games, the maker of GTA6, decided on fully digital distribution. The game is not playable without access to the internet, and it cannot be shared, lent, or resold in any form. And if the company decides that it’s no longer profitable to keep the game running, they can shut it down, and everyone who thought they paid for a game will realize they paid for a “digital permission slip,” at the sole discretion of corporate executives. Users have no recourse in this scenario, and certainly no refunds for a game that can be unilaterally taken away from them without their input. That’s a grand theft, but not the one implied by the game title.

“It would be like if every copy of a book that is printed is destroyed at the same time,” said Ross Scott of Stop Killing Games, an advocacy campaign fighting for legal protections for gamers. “It would be like if you went into a museum and set fire to one of the paintings.”

The Prospect in your inbox

Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.

No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.

Scott’s organization hosted a Twitch stream on Thursday about the hazards of digital distribution with Players Alliance HQ, a coalition of gamers taking on corporate greed in the video game industry. “We’re fighting for digital ownership so we can actually own something we pay for,” said Olivia Pettersson, one of the group’s leaders. “How do I give this disc to a friend if I don’t want this game anymore?”

By the metric of revenue, the video game industry is larger than the music, film, and TV industries combined. More than two-thirds of Americans play video games weekly, an enormous audience of players who’ve been largely unaware of their diminishing consumer rights. They have seen massive consolidation among major studios and publishers, and a growing breakdown in how games are produced, sold, and maintained. Their desire to play games and have fun has been exploited for massive profits.

Players Alliance, established nearly two years ago by expats from the labor movement, was built to fight back. The idea was to get frustrated gamers organized as a political force to assert their rights. It turns out that they were pushing on an open door. The organization and others like Stop Killing Games have exploded in membership over the past year, while making inroads with U.S. and international lawmakers. It’s one of the most fascinating grassroots efforts happening today, and the action around GTA6 and its digital distribution could be their biggest fight yet. I talked to several Players Alliance members to understand what they want from a pastime they love, and why they think they can get it.

OTIS EAST, A FOUNDING MEMBER OF PLAYERS ALLIANCE, describes himself as “a nerd from Chicago” who has been “gaming since I knew how to talk.” That’s literally true; his dad got him a Sega Genesis when he was two. His biggest complaint with gaming since he got started is that its devotees are used as guinea pigs for economic experiments that then migrate to other sectors.

That includes moving from physical cartridges that had to be inserted into consoles to the subscription-based model, where you pay monthly for access to a game, a phenomenon that has begun to dominate everything from streaming services to printer ink. Small payments inside games—sometimes the only way to win is to pony up—started a corporate trend to maximize revenue in tiny doses after an initial purchase. “Buying something once isn’t enough anymore, corporations are figuring out, how do we get people to buy things 100 times,” said Joseph Grover, one of the founding members of Players Alliance, who goes by Prizzo in the gaming world.

Grover’s first system was an original Game Boy when he was five. “I’m sure you’ve heard of the term ‘enshittification’; that perfectly encapsulates the entire gaming industry right now,” he told me. He mentioned a game called Tribes Ascend, something he put at least $200 into, buying additional weapons and skins, until the studio shut down the servers. The community put a version of the game back online, but it was not the same. “You have no rights, no control,” he said. “They can squeeze you for money and take it away.”

Such practices artificially limit the supply of games and help companies increase prices. A new report from the American Economic Liberties Project shows that prices for subscriptions and rentals of video games increased by 14.4 percent over a 12-month period from September 2025 to September 2026, a level that is nearly four times as fast as the current elevated inflation figures.

The beneficiaries are some of the biggest companies and financiers on the planet. Microsoft acquired large game publisher Activision in 2023 and owns the popular Xbox console; since that merger, the cost of Microsoft’s Game Pass subscription service has shot up 53 percent to $23 a month, while publishers like Halo Studios have been shuttered. Sony is a major game maker and distributor with its dominant PlayStation console, the price of which has also gone up. Both companies have vertically integrated at all levels of the supply chain and engaged in serial acquisitions that inevitably lead to shutdowns and layoffs.

Cost has become a huge pain point for gamers. They compete for memory and computer chips with data centers powering AI; the term “RAMageddon” has been used to describe the price spike, with gamers suddenly in competition with the biggest companies in the world. RAM (random-access memory) for gaming PCs has doubled or even tripled in price.

Electronic Arts, makers of the Madden NFL series and The Sims, was bought out this summer for $55 billion by the sovereign wealth fund of Saudi Arabia, private equity firm Silver Lake, and Jared Kushner’s investment company Affinity Partners. It was among the biggest leveraged buyouts ever, leaving EA with $20 billion in debt. The buyout, sparking concerns about both the authoritarian influence on a gaming company and the usual damage private equity portends, was the impetus for one of Players Alliance’s first major campaigns.

Organizing was done online through Discord servers and social media, and also in real life at conventions and player meetups. Quickly, the group realized how much energy they could draw on, channeling inchoate grumbling into political action. “I feel like any gamer will feel the exact same frustrations,” Grover said. “It’s why this group has so much potential: It’s such a big spectrum of people. You can be right-leaning or left-leaning and can agree with what we’re saying.”

Rep. Maxwell Frost (D-FL) speaks with Sims content creators lilsimsie and Zefrine on a livestream about the Electronic Arts buyout. Credit: Screenshot/YouTube.

Eventually, Players Alliance got 70,000 signatures on a petition to stop the buyout. Content creators joined the efforts, including lilsimsie, who broadcast about the buyout to her 2.24 million YouTube subscribers and did a livestream with Rep. Maxwell Frost (D-FL). The campaign even conducted live direct actions, like a “raid” to take on the big boss at EA’s main campus in Redwood City, California.  

Zefrine, another Sims content creator, was involved with the campaign and the livestream, despite being part of the EA Creator Program, a partnership with the company. “I’m a full-time content creator so this is like my bread and butter,” she said. “But I have this platform that has been entrusted upon me for thousands of people who have these same issues … So I think that was important for me to do.”

Players Alliance didn’t stop the buyout—a subsequent action at an EA office in Orlando after the closure of the deal was termed a “gamer funeral”—but its leaders feel like it expanded its organizing vision for the future. “We actually got the attention of the government, we got the attention of the company,” Pettersson said.“While it wasn’t an overall success, there were so many smaller successes along the way that made me realize how possible doing something actually is.”

Meanwhile, the expectation that the private equity buyout would lead to lessened quality and worker dislocation was quickly proven correct. EA disbanded the 31-year-old studio BioWare after one of its games performed poorly, laying off 400 workers, stranding a new edition of Mass Effect, and putting its large library at risk.

DIGITAL OWNERSHIP AFFECTS A MUCH LARGER SLICE of the gaming world than one studio. Sony is ending physical disc production for all of its games by 2028. With GTA6 following suit, most gamers expect that every future release will only be available by digital download without the ability to transfer. (GTA6 is initially launching on PlayStation, forcing gamers like Rep. Frost to buy the console.)

The clear implication is a shift in control from the purchaser to the distributor. “What a bummer to open an empty box,” said Pettersson, who learned about Players Alliance from Prizzo and works to facilitate the group’s general organizing meetings. “If someone came up to me and said, ‘Pay me $50 for a link,’ I’d say, ‘no,’ I’d think I’m getting scammed.”

In some cases, that feels exactly like what’s happening. Some buyers have opened the GTA6 box to not only find no disc, but no download code either, just a small poster and no way to play the game. They also report that Rockstar Games support has failed to give them refunds. 

Not only are companies eliminating the costs associated with physical distribution without discounting the product, but the ban on creating digital copies prevents the $7.2 billion resale market from surviving, forcing people who want new gaming experiences to buy new games. And games can be destroyed, wiped off the map, simply by shutting off the servers, vaporizing the time and effort and money players put into the game. Older games are simply no longer accessible.

A shot from the GTA 6 trailer, released in September. Credit: Francois Greuez/Sipa via AP Images.

The Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998 bars circumvention of whatever digital lock is on a game. It makes breaking that lock a crime punishable by fines and even imprisonment. Combined with the consolidation in the industry, this gives massive companies a huge hammer to prevent competition and restrict rights.

The result is that customers will simply never actually own the games they buy, and will have to wonder at all times whether they will lose access or the ability to share the experience. You can’t even put games from a digital store into your will; if the account holder is found to have passed away, the account is wound down. “Having to tell your future kids what your password and login is, that’s kind of crazy,” said Pettersson.

The move to digital downloads has also destroyed independent gaming stores, which now have shifted to selling merchandise instead of the games that anyone can get online. That threatens the community aspect of gaming in real life. “This will be the end of a lot of small local businesses, it’s a whole industry that’s completely dying,” said Grover. Two game stores, Loot Box Gaming and Video Games Plus, are protesting the digital distribution of GTA6 by refusing to sell it.

The gaming industry says they need to crack down on piracy by restricting resales. But the profits they are reaping should dispel the image of poor studios just trying to recoup their investment; revenues for the industry crossed $200 billion in 2025. Meanwhile, prices keep jumping to the extent that gamers have to rent consoles or PCs to afford the luxury; the move is on toward a future where no gamer owns anything associated with video games.

Coalitions like Stop Killing Games and Players Alliance have taken action to end digital-only ownership. SKG has corresponded with consumer protection agencies around the world, and actions in France, Germany, and Australia are pending. There was a citizen’s initiative to reform digital ownership in the European Union that had over one million signatures and is on track for a legislative effort in the European Parliament.

A bill in the California legislature called the Protect Our Games Act that would have required companies to give 60 days notice before shutting down a game and provide alternative access didn’t make it past the state Senate this year, but lawmakers plan to try again. A similar effort is launching in New York; Assemblymember Ron Kim appeared on the Twitch stream on Wednesday to announce it. “As a consumer, I’m paying $75, I think I own this shit,” he said. “I can’t give this to my kid if I don’t want this anymore? This is completely predatory.”

Rep. Frost announced a federal version of the California legislation on Wednesday. Rep. Ritchie Torres (D-NY) has also offered a bill to allow the Federal Trade Commission to issue a rule to protect gamer libraries, but that would be much more time-consuming and uncertain than a bright-line law from Congress.

The Prospect in your inbox

Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.

No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.

Gamers have also filed lawsuits against companies like Sony, which has pushed back by saying that it is the true owner of all its games, and that no reasonable consumer “would believe that they were obtaining ‘ownership.’” Much of this activity has been pushed into binding arbitration, because gaming companies include arbitration clauses in all of their purchases.

Advocates want to see open distribution of video games so that companies don’t have the pipeline locked up and can therefore restrict ownership or threaten shutdowns. They also want to break up the big gaming studios, end forced arbitration for purchasing a video game, and eliminate the restrictions on circumvention of digital locks in favor of normal copyright law.

“Congress needs to require companies to make it so people can still play games even if the server shuts down,” said Ashley Nowicki of the American Economic Liberties Project, who co-authored the report.

Players Alliance members see their movement as just getting started and destined for bigger things. “It’s a gateway drug into politics,” Grover said. “We have a gun-owning rancher and then also a gay activist from San Francisco, and they’re in the same chat, working together on the same goals … People are starting to wake up to the fact that these corporations have no regard for you, your wallet, anything except maximizing profits.”

Before taking on the world, they’re taking on the video game industry. “We’re not like those kids sitting in the basement, sweating over Mortal Kombat or whatever games on your Nintendo 64,” Zefrine said. “We’re a very powerful economic force.”

David Dayen is the executive editor of The American Prospect. He is the author of Monopolized: Life in the Age of Corporate Power and Chain of Title: How Three Ordinary Americans Uncovered Wall Street’s Great Foreclosure Fraud. He co-hosts the podcast Organized Money with Matt Stoller. He can be reached on Signal at ddayen.90.