Read the top story of the day in your inbox. Sign up for the Daily Prospect newsletter here.
When the new Congress convenes in January, Democrats will have many enormous messes to start cleaning up—and one of them is at the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA). Rep. Mark Takano (D-CA)—now the ranking member of the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs (HVAC), who will become its new chair—has pledged to act as a “check” on VA Secretary Doug Collins.
The core problem, as we have covered at the Prospect, is greatly accelerated VA privatization. Takano is planning to investigate the link between “DOGE inspired workforce cuts” at the VA last year—now totaling some 35,000 layoffs—and the growing number of patients being referred to outside health care providers, where many have experienced “delays, denials, and network failures.”
The Prospect in your inbox
Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.
No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.
According to Takano, HVAC’s expanded oversight efforts will include a major focus on cost cutting, contracting out, and reorganization schemes that have not improved organizational efficiency. He has also pledged to find ways to “strengthen VA’s direct care system while protecting it from privatization” over the next two years. This is good—and with any luck, the new class of Democrats joining Congress will join the fight.
Democrats’ sweeping midterm victory should make Takano’s job easier—as well as that of Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), slated to become chair of the Senate Committee on Veterans’ Affairs (SVAC). They will be replacing two staunch allies of Collins: Rep. Mike Bost (R-IL) and Sen. Jerry Moran (R-KS). Both have received past financial support from the Koch brothers and other privatization fans.
What’s more, HVAC will finally be rid of Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks, an Iowa Republican who used her status as a veteran and physician to promote VA outsourcing. Health care and pharmaceutical companies have donated over $450,000 to her past campaigns, but she still lost by almost ten points.
This might not be a coincidence. Voters favored VA privatization foes like former Army paratrooper Richard Ojeda in North Carolina; former Marine drill instructor JoAnna Mendoza in Arizona (who has been treated for military sexual trauma at the VA); former Army surgeon Adam Hamawy in New Jersey (who once saved the life and right arm of former Army pilot and now-Sen. Tammy Duckworth of Illinois); and West Point graduate Fred Wellman in Missouri.
Mitchell Berman, who served as a VA nurse for more than a decade, will now represent former Republican vice-presidential candidate Paul Ryan’s old district in Wisconsin. Michigan’s new senator, Abdul El-Sayed, a former public-health physician and Medicare for All advocate, opposes VA privatization.
In Iowa, Democratic Sen.-elect Josh Turek suffered birth defects due to his father’s Agent Orange exposure during service in Vietnam. He has promised to ensure that “veterans exposed to toxic substances during their military service get the care and benefits they need.”
In the past, many new members have viewed serving on veterans’ affairs committees as less prestigious (and less lucrative for fundraising) than roles on higher-profile committees. But the VA is a massive piece of American health care in serious disarray. As one former Senate staffer told the Prospect, it’s now a critical Capitol Hill role “for anyone who wants to see genuine health care reform in this country.”
A Medical Records Fiasco
A top priority for Democrats should be halting the disruption of patient record handling caused by a new electronic health record (EHR) system introduced by Collins.
As Edward Meagher, a former deputy assistant secretary for information technology at the VA, has written in a comprehensive report, this costly fiasco can be traced back to decisions made in 2017. That’s when the White House began the process, led by Jared Kushner and Ivanka Trump, of awarding a no-bid contract to Cerner Corporation (now owned by Oracle) to “modernize” VA patient recordkeeping.
The VA already had an electronic health recordkeeping system, developed in-house, called VistA, which works perfectly well. The replacement product from Cerner/Oracle was engineered to help health care companies increase their revenue. So it shouldn’t be surprising that bloated costs have been a predictable consequence of the Cerner deal, which is now expected to cost as much as $50 billion, not the $10 billion originally projected.
But worse, since it was rolled out in six smaller VA facilities, the new system created problems: documented patient harm, reduced productivity, and widespread demoralization of caregivers.
This Veterans Day, various veterans’ advocates highlighted the EHR problem with a trailer for a new film. Among other things, this Stop the Rollout campaign points out that Oracle/Cerner is now getting $100 million a month to make VA recordkeeping worse.
The story is crying out for aggressive oversight—and on December 10th, Democrats will have a chance. Oracle CEO Larry Ellison and co-CEO Mike Sicilia have been subpoenaed to appear before HVAC after failing to show up at its September 2nd session. Other Oracle officials were summoned to a Senate hearing on November 18th.
For example, these executives ought to answer for Charlie Bourg. He’s a 71-year-old Vietnam veteran who lives in Spokane, Washington. In December 2020, Bourg’s primary care physician at the VA tried to refer him to a urologist using the EHR system after an elevated prostate-specific antigen test. The referral promptly disappeared into an EHR abyss known as an “unknown queue.” By the time the error was discovered over a year later, Bourg’s cancer was terminal.
Using the Power of the Purse?
When the new Congress convenes in January, Democrats could try to halt the EHR rollout by denying the funding for it. The Senate staffer told the Prospect that Congress should also appropriate funds for an independent comparison of Oracle’s EHR to the old VistA system, which is still being used in VA facilities all over the country. As part of that process, Democrats should insist that Collins restore a report on how health care records move from VistA into the new system that the department suspiciously deleted, along with any other relevant information.
Another possible use of the congressional checkbook is halting Collins’s overcentralization. He wants to slash the number of Veterans Integrated Service Networks (VISNs) from 18 to five. As the Prospect has reported, this consolidation will worsen bureaucratic snafus, costing the VA about $521 million during its first year and an additional $321 million over five years. Already, Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz (D-FL) has warned Collins at a recent House Oversight Committee hearing that funding for this plan could be curtailed.
Claims Processing Delays
Democrats also ought to focus on Collins’s cuts to the Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA), the part of the agency that handles benefit claims for service-related disabilities. “Starting in January 2025, the Trump administration began illegally firing thousands of VBA staff—a third of them were veterans—who were processing veterans’ disability claims,” says Paul Sullivan, a VA expert and former agency official. “Since January 2025, VBA’s total inventory of all types of claims has risen from [about] 900,000 to more than 1.6 million.”
According to the VA Office of Inspector General and outside reporting, VBA’s error rates are skyrocketing. Part of the problem may be because of VBA’s increasing use of error-prone AI tools to automate claims processing. Sullivan argues that instead VBA’s staffing, training, and funding should be increased.
Incidentally, the mess at VBA has inflated a business of “claim sharks,” sketchy private businesses, not licensed by the VA, that promise to help veterans get their benefits. The companies then donate to President Trump and relevant congressional Republicans, like SVAC member Dan Sullivan of Alaska. That may be one reason why Sullivan lost to Mary Peltola.
Impact of Staffing Cuts
As noted above, in fiscal year 2025 the VA shed more than 35,000 health care positions—the first annual net loss in the department’s history. Among them: 1,000 physicians, 3,000 registered nurses, and 1,500 schedulers. An estimated 1.2 million veterans lost their VA provider. At multiple 2027 hearings, one Senate staffer argues, “we have to get more information from the administration so that we can find out why they made the decisions they did on positions they said were no longer needed and that were thus erased.”
Collins has insisted that last year’s cuts didn’t affect or impede the functioning of frontline staff, like doctors and nurses. This claim—which assumes that support staff are not also essential to care delivery in any health care system—should be challenged. Indeed, reporting by the Prospect and ProPublica has already revealed that hospital maintenance deficiencies are a threat to the safety of VA patients.
Collins should face renewed questioning about the impact of his “return to office” directives. These have led radiologists, mental health professionals, and many others to leave the VHA. Have resulting staffing shortages harmed veterans?
We also need to know more about the VA fallout of Russell Vought’s OMB drive to make federal employment “a nightmare.” Has the resulting hostile work environment that many VA caregivers have experienced since then made recruiting their replacements more difficult?
Threats to Teaching, Research, and Recruitment
Congress should also examine the state of VA training. If a record-breaking 60 million VA-funded patient appointments are now with outside providers, the nation’s largest public health care system will lack opportunities for new health care professionals to learn to practice their craft. For example, one West Coast medical center has just suspended its recruitment of new candidates for fellowships in geriatric neurology (i.e., dementia), Parkinson’s, and multiple sclerosis.
As a doctor privy to the situation told the Prospect, “This is a big hit, and I worry that it’s going to hurt recruitment of neurologists who are trained to take care of vets at the VA.” Congress—and VA patients—need to know how bad this trend has gotten.
The VA’s critical research mission is likewise undermined by privatization and outsourcing. When millions of patients are treated outside its system, there is far less encouragement and support for patient enrollment in VA research studies.
The Prospect in your inbox
Analysis that goes beyond the noise with in-depth, progressive reporting.
No paywall, no programmatic ads — just the reporting. Unsubscribe anytime. Submitting your email signs you up for The Daily Prospect, our weekday morning newsletter.
If patient data then has to be retrieved from 1.7 million outside vendors (if it can be found at all), researchers will struggle to study the hundreds of thousands of veterans who have been exposed to toxic substances—the same ones who supposedly gained easier access to the VA, thanks to the passage of the PACT Act four years ago. Researchers will also struggle to identify new service-related problems if veterans are scattered across a fragmented health care system.
In the past, VA medical research—which led to the first implantable cardiac pacemaker, the shingles vaccine, and hundreds of other innovations—was facilitated by its large, stable population of both patients and career clinicians. If that doesn’t exist anymore, the health of veterans and the public alike will suffer.
Putting Down Markers for 2029
Even if Trump vetoes all of the Democrats’ proposals for the VA over the next two years, Democrats can still put down legislative markers. They have already done this by introducing VA-related bills that would clearly help veterans and the federal workers who serve them.
Examples of this already exist in the form of the Honor Our Promise to Veterans Act, introduced by Blumenthal in the Senate. It attempts to address myriad issues, including VA staffing shortages and Collins’s damaging expansion of outsourcing.
The Ensuring Veterans’ Smooth Transition (EVEST) Act is a longtime Takano project. If enacted, every service member transitioning out of the military would be initially enrolled in the VA, regardless of whether they are later able to prove their health care eligibility based on low income or having a service-related condition.
Finally, Democrats should put Trump and the GOP on the spot by forcing a vote on the Protect America’s Workforce Act. Trump stripped collective-bargaining rights from about one million federal workers; this law would restore those rights—including at the VA where Collins is fighting a legal battle with the American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE) over his allegedly unlawful termination of collective bargaining with it and other unions.
It’s unlikely that Trump would sign any of that, though not impossible. But with hard work and a bit of luck, lawmakers can keep the damage to the VA to a minimum, then fix it properly under a Democratic administration in 2029.
